Greater Greater Washington

Posts by Matt Johnson

Matt Johnson has lived in the Washington area since 2007. He has a Master's in Planning from the University of Maryland and a BS in Public Policy from Georgia Tech. He lives in Greenbelt. Hes a member of the American Institute of Certified Planners. He is a contract employee of the Montgomery County Planning Department. His views are his own and do not represent those of his employer. 

Here are the answers to whichWMATA week 70

On Tuesday, we posted our seventieth photo challenge to see how well you knew Metro. I took photos of five Metro stations. Here are the answers. How well did you do?

This week, we got 39 guesses. Twelve got all five. Great work, Roger Bowles, Peter K, Russell H, JamesDCane, AlexC, Jack M, Solomon, Mike B, Chris H, MZEBE, Mr Johnson, and FN!

Image 1: U Street

The first image shows the Vermont Avenue entrance to U Street. The primary clue here is the statue visible in the distance. That's the African American Civil War Memorial, which lent its name to the station. The statue stands in the plaza at the corner of Vermont and U, where the eastern entrance to the station is located.

Twenty-nine guessed correctly.

Image 2: Rosslyn

The second photo shows the escalator shaft at Rosslyn. This shaft contains the fifth-longest bank of escalators in the system. The moving steps here span 194 feet, behind only Wheaton, Bethesda, Woodley Park, and Medical Center.

The primary identifying feature here is the elevator shaft at center. At Rosslyn, there are four escalators, with an elevator shaft sitting in the middle. This is the only station with this arrangement. No other station has four long escalators and no other station has an elevator piercing the escalator shaft. This elevator has been decommissioned, replaced by a bank of three elevators at the station's new east entrance.

Thirty-five knew this was Rosslyn.

Image 3: Stadium/Armory

The third picture shows the northern entrance to Stadium/Armory, looking down toward the trainroom and platform. This view is unique in the system. At virtually every underground station, you enter the trainroom above the tracks at mezzanine level. There, you go through fare control and then descend to the platform.

But at three stations—Union Station, Farragut North, and Stadium/Armory—one of the mezzanines is located outside the trainroom, and you actually enter the train room through the end wall at platform level. In this case, you can see the tall "doorway" around the escalators, which wouldn't be necessary if the mezzanine floated above the platform.

At Union Station (north), there are two escalators split by an elevator. At Farragut North (north), there are three side-by-side escalators, but the ceiling isn't vaulted at this end to make way for a (formerly) planned underground ramp to I-66.

The only station that fits is Stadium/Armory. You also could have confirmed that by noting the signage at the foreground. "New Carrollton" and "Largo Town Center" are readable on the sign to the left, indicating that this is a Blue/Orange/Silver station. Thirty scored a goal on this one.

Image 4: West Hyattsville

The fourth image was taken at West Hyattsville. This station has side platforms, which is what allows this vantage point. The sloped roof here holds the skylights that are above the escalators to the Greenbelt platform. The parking lot is in the background. This is a station with unique architecture, and this sloped roof is only present at West Hyattsville. Huntington (south) has a similar escalator covering, but it isn't visible from anywhere other than below (as we did in week 12).

Additionally, the vertical bars close to the camera are parts of a fence that WMATA installed along the platform wall a year or so ago and this fence is unique to West Hyattsville. Seventeen figured it out.

Image 5: Cleveland Park

The final image was the hardest. It shows the staircase at Cleveland Park. You can tell from the design of the vault that this is an Arch I station, which is a type only present on the Red Line between Woodley Park and Medical Center.

However, of those stations, the only place where an escalator and staircase are next to each other is Cleveland Park. At the other stations with this design, the end of the mezzanine is capped with a pair of escalators. Only at Cleveland Park is the solitary escalator accompanied by a stair. Twenty-one guessed correctly.

Next week, we'll have five more photos for you to identify. Thanks for playing!

Information about contest rules, submission guidelines, and a leaderboard is available at

Think you know Metro? It's whichWMATA week 70

It's time for the seventieth installment of our weekly "whichWMATA" series! Below are photos of 5 stations in the Washington Metro system. Can you identify each from its picture?

Image 1

Image 2

Image 3

Image 4

Image 5

Please have your answers in by noon on Thursday. We'll hide the comments so the early birds don't spoil the fun for the rest of you.

The answers will appear on Thursday. Good luck! UPDATE: The answers are here.

Information about contest rules, submission guidelines, and a leaderboard is available at

Chicago has examples of a cheap way to bring rail transit to more people: infill stations

North of Union Station, the Metro station at NoMa is Washington's only "infill" station. Another is planned at Potomac Yard. In Chicago, where the CTA has been working on infill stations for several years, there's proof that the stations can be added cheaply.

Cermak/McCormick Place. Photo by the author.

Infill stations are new stations constructed between stations on an existing transit line. NoMa, for example, opened in 2004. It was built between the existing stations at Union Station and Rhode Island Avenue along tracks that had opened in 1976.

The Chicago L dates back over a century. In many places its iconic, rickety structures pass through the dense, vibrant neighborhoods they helped to create. But after World War II, when the CTA took over service, many stations were closed to make trips from the outlying branches faster and to bring down expenses.

In recent years, CTA has reopened several of these stations, which is a more intensive process than it sounds like because the old stations weren't just abandoned; they were demolished.

A few months ago, the agency opened a new station on the Green Line at Cermak/McCormick Place. The station has a gorgeous vaulted canopy. In this location, there's a former stretch of third track, which became platform space.

McCormick Place. Photo by the author.

But because the platform is so narrow, CTA didn't want to have any columns obstructing it. The solution was the vault, supported from outside the trackway. The station cost relatively cheap $50 million. (Yes, fifty million).

Across town, the Morgan station recently opened on the Green and Pink Lines. It was even cheaper to construct, coming in at just $38 million.

This station was also located where a former station had been removed in 1948. It has proven very popular, and was also fairly cheap and quick to construct.

Morgan. Photo by the author.

The Yellow Line is also home to an infill station at Oakton. That station was a recent additon to the line, which formerly had no intermediate stops between Skokie/Dempster and Howard.

In Washington, our infill stations tend to be a little more expensive because they're designed with wider platforms and sturdier materials. Also, in both the case of NoMa and Potomac Yard, the new stations required relocating the tracks. That was not the case in Chicago.

Where would you like to see an infill station on Metro?

Metro wants to connect Farragut North and West with a tunnel

Since 2004, Metro has been planning to build an underground connection between Farragut North and Farragut West. The two busy downtown stations are only 400 feet apart, and a connection could provide an attractive alternative to Metro Center, currently the only transfer point between the Red and Blue/Orange/Silver lines.

People walking between the Farragut stations. They would be able to connect underground if Metro builds this connector. All images from WMATA unless otherwise noted.

This was supposed to happen in the original plan

The Red Line crosses the Blue/Orange/Silver Line twice: once at Metro Center, where passengers can transfer between trains, and again at Connecticut and I Street at the southeast corner of Farragut Square. Early plans for the Metro system called for a single Farragut Square station, with two levels allowing transfers like at Metro Center.

But the National Park Service balked at allowing WMATA to dig up the square to build a station there, since it would mean killing the old trees in the square. As a result, there are two separate stations, one at Farragut North for the Red Line and one at Farragut West for the Blue/Orange/Silver Lines.

Metro lines and entrances around Farragut square.

That means that riders coming from Virginia who want to head northwest on the Red Line have to stay on the train longer, riding past Farragut and McPherson Squares and doubling back at Metro Center, the busiest station in the system.

In 2011, Metro instituted a "virtual tunnel" called Farragut Crossing that allows riders to exit one Farragut and enter the other Farragut using a SmarTrip card without incurring an additional fare surcharge. However, this free transfer requires crossing three streets (K, I, and 17th) and walking a block outside. On weekends and for wheelchair users, the transfer also requires an additional block and crossing 18th Street.

Photo by Dan Malouff.

Metro officials are continuing to work on the connector because it will provide necessary congestion relief at Metro Center and will shorten many riders' trips. However, they're also planning additional improvements in Farragut North and Farragut West since the tunnel will increase usage there.

Beyond the tunnel, stations would need greater capacity

There are three primary components in the project.

The biggest element is the tunnel itself, which will stretch about 450 feet between the eastern (17th Street) mezzanine at Farragut West to the south end of Farragut North. The entire tunnel will be in the fare-paid area. In the current plans, there would be no new entrances built along the tunnel.

Ways Farragut North and West could be connected.

Another part of the project calls for Farragut North to be able to handle more traffic. This means new staircases between the central/south mezzanine and the platform, redundant street and platform elevators, and reconfigured faregates.

Changes to the center mezzanine at Farragut North.

One of WMATA's design options also would extend the central/south mezzanine so it connects directly to the tunnel to Farragut West. That option improves circulation since it allows passengers to avoid the platform.

Connector at Farragut North, option 2.

The final component of the project would expand capacity at Farragut West by extending the mezzanines on both the east and western ends, adding platform and street elevators at the eastern mezzanine, and reconfiguring the fare vending machines and faregates.

Extension to the west mezzanine at Farragut West.

The project would have the added benefit of making Farragut North and Farragut West elevator-redundant stations, improving the accessibility of the system.

This would save time and ease congestion

The largest benefit is time savings for transferring riders. Without the tunnel, planners estimate that under crowded conditions in 2030 the tunnel would reduce travel time between the Farraguts from 6:14 (via Metro Center) or 7:51 (via 17th Street) to 3:19 (via the tunnel). The time savings is even greater during uncongested periods, with a reduction from 5:35 (via Metro Center) or 6:17 (via 17th Street) to 1:39 (via the tunnel).

Another advantage of the tunnel is that it would reduce crowding at Metro Center. Today, there are almost 85,000 daily transfers at Metro Center (in addition to about 56,000 daily entries and exits). Without the tunnel, the number of transfers at Metro Center is expected to climb to over 100,000 by 2030, with daily entries and exits rising to about 70,000.

Crowding at Metro Center.

With the tunnel, transfers at Metro Center would drop to around 78,000 by 2030, less than the number today. That's because approximately 26,000 riders would elect to transfer between the Farraguts rather than at Metro Center.

Additionally, the proposed improvements at Farragut North and Farragut West inside the stations could reduce congestion on the platforms.

The current arrangement of escalators at Farragut North's central and southern mezzanines concentrates passengers in the center of the platform. New staircases on either end of the mezzanine would better distribute passengers and reduce crowding.

Crowding at Farragut North.

At Farragut West, the four additional escalators would clear the platform more quickly, though they would likely increase congestion in the mezzanines.

Costs could be spread out

The project doesn't have to happen all at once. The pieces could probably be broken out, though it could be easier or less disruptive to build them together.

The tunnel itself is estimated to cost between $70 and $73 million. The Farragut North improvements would cost around $23 million. The Farragut West construction would run about $36 million. That brings the total cost to around $130 million.

However, this study hasn't fleshed out all the issues. Metro still needs to conduct additional analysis to determine some of the structural elements and do further design work.

Funding hasn't yet been identified, nor has a timeline for construction. However, the study does anticipate the tunnel being open by 2030.

These Metro stations have backup elevators

If you've ever needed an elevator to get in or out of a Metro station but the one at the station you were using wasn't working, you probably had to ride a shuttle to or from the next-closest station with a working one. Some stations, however, have redundant elevators, meaning there is more than one elevator for every possible trip, including every platform and mezzanine, plus the sidewalk.

Graphic by the author.

Metro decided around 2003 to install redundant elevators at new stations so that even if an elevator goes out of service, a person in a wheelchair can still access every part of the station and won't need to take a shuttle to another station.

The typical setup can break down in multiple places

At most stations, those who require the use of an elevator have to use more than one. In cases like this, there's one elevator going from the street to the mezzanine. Then there's a second elevator going from the mezzanine to the platform. At side platform stations, there would be one for each platform.

If either of those elevators is out of service, the station isn't accessible and Metro has to run shuttle service.

At a few stations, the elevator runs directly from the street to the platform(s). That's the case at Judiciary Square, for instance.

Some Metro stations have more than one mezzanine, with an entrance from each. But very few of those stations have elevator access at more than one of those. For example, Dupont Circle has entrances at Q Street (north mezzanine) and 19th Street (south mezzanine). But only the Q Street entrance has elevator access.

There's a new norm that avoids the problem

Stations constructed or renovated since 2003 have redundant elevators. This can take two forms. In one case, a station with two entrances has non-redundant elevators at both entrances. In the other case, one entrance has at least two elevators for every movement.

The first station to have redundant elevators was actually Friendship Heights. The northern mezzanine opened with the station in 1984 and has (non-redundant) elevators leading to the surface. The southern entrance, which opened in 1985, includes a bank of four high-speed elevators leading to the street instead of escalators.

However, there's only one mezzanine-to-platform elevator at the Friendship Heights southern mezzanine, so the entrance is not itself redundant. But since both entrances have elevators and are just two blocks apart, the station is still accessible when one elevator breaks.

The second station with redundant elevators was Forest Glen, which has one elevator-only entrance. The five elevators go directly from the platform to the mezzanine, which is at street level. That station opened in 1990.

The first station to get redundant elevators under Metro's new policy was Mount Vernon Square, which was renovated as part of the construction of the convention center in 2003. At Mount Vernon Square, there's only one entrance, but there are three elevators elevators going between the street and the mezzanine—three have to be broken to prevent access. There are also two elevators between the mezzanine and the platform. As long as one is functioning, people can still make the movement.

2006 saw the construction of a new northern entrance at King Street station, which includes an elevator, making the station redundant.

Navy Yard became redundant in 2008 when the Half Street entrance was reconstructed in preparation for Nats Park. Prior to that time, the New Jersey Avenue entrance was the only entrance with elevator access. Now both entrances are accessible: at both, there's one elevator from the street to the mezzanine and one from the mezzanine to the platform.

Additionally, Metro opened three stations in 2004, each of which included redundant elevators: Largo, Morgan Boulevard, and NoMa. The five recently-opened Silver Line stations are also redundant.

Two stations are partially redundant. Gallery Place got new street elevators as part of the construction of the Verizon Center in 1997. The station has redundant elevators between the Glenmont platform and the street only. Access to the Green/Yellow and Shady Grove platforms is not redundant.

Rosslyn is also redundant for elevator users between the street and the inbound platform. A new entrance opened in 2013, replacing the former solitary elevator between the inbound platform and the street. The new entrance has three high-speed elevators which go directly from the street to the inbound platform. However, there is still just one elevator between the inbound and outbound platforms, so the station is not fully redundant.

Future redundant stations

Construction should start soon on a new entrance at Medical Center. Currently, the station has one mezzanine, with a single elevator leading from the platform to the mezzanine and a second elevator (and a bank of three escalators) leading to the west side of Rockville Pike at the National Institutes of Health.

In a few months, Montgomery County will start work on a new elevator-only entrance on the east side of Rockville Pike directly across from the current entrance. Three high-speed elevators will lead to the existing mezzanine, which will be renovated to include a second platform elevator and a new staircase. The project is expected to be complete in 2018.

Arlington is constructing a western entrance to Ballston which will have redundant elevators. That project is expected to be completed in 2021.

Additionally, as a part of the Purple Line project, new entrances will be added at Bethesda and Silver Spring in 2021.

At Bethesda, a new south entrance will include redundant platform to mezzanine elevators and four high-speed mezzanine to Purple Line elevators. The new entrance will be located a few blocks south of the current entrance, emerging at Wisconsin and Elm.

Silver Spring will get a third entrance, located at the southern end of the platform. The new mezzanine will be located above the platform, roughly aligned with the third level of the newly-opened Sarbanes Transit Center. The Purple Line platform will be located above that connection, on the fourth level of the center.

Metro has some other projects on the radar that would include redundant elevators. However, as of right now, these projects aren't funded, so they may or may not happen. One such project includes plans to reconfigure the northern entrance to Union Station, which would include two sets of redundant elevators.

Additionally, the agency has plans to make Farragut North and Farragut West redundant as part of the proposed pedestrian connection between those stations.

In the future, some stations may get new entrances, which would make them redundant. But none are currently in active planning.

Here are the answers to whichWMATA week 69

On Tuesday, we posted our sixty-ninth photo challenge to see how well you knew Metro. I took photos of five Metro stations. Here are the answers. How well did you do?

This week we got 17 guesses. Only one person got all five. Great work, Peter K!

Image 1: Addison Road

This week wasn't exactly themed, but as Peter figured out, there was a pattern. The five stations were arranged alphabetically by their first letter, A-B-C-D-E.

The first image shows the view of Addison Road from the bridge to the parking deck. You can see that this is one of the "general peak" stations. Of the general peak stations with a mezzanine above the tracks, only three are not in the median of I-66. And the setting and angle doesn't work for Grosvenor or White Flint.

Fourteen got this one right.

Image 2: Brookland

The second image proved to be very difficult. The sign pictured here is located on the west side of the Brookland station, mounted to a bridge pier supporting Michigan Avenue. It's necessary because the western entrance to Brookland is not elevator-accessible. To get to the elevator, passengers have to use a circuitous route, crossing over the station on Monroe Street.

There were a few clues here, including the sign itself, which is unique as far as I am aware. Additionally, this would only be placed where the escalator and elevator entrances were separated by some distance. There are a few Red Line stations where that's the case, including Takoma, Brookland, Woodley Park, and Bethesda.

But the sign is also mounted on a high wall with a mural. And that means it has to be Brookland. Only three people were successful on this one.

Image 3: Congress Heights

The third image shows a view of the escalators to the bus loop at Congress Heights. This is, as Peter K noted, a 180-degree view to one of the pictures featured in week 57.

The escalator canopy in the distance is only present at the three subway stations opened between 1999 and 2001. But this can only be Congress Heights. At Georgia Avenue, none of the escalator shafts have three escalators and a staircase, as this one does. And at Columbia Heights, the staircase is to the left of the three escalators. Here, it's just visible to the right.

But the main way to differentiate Congress Heights from Columbia Heights and Georgia Avenue are the fluorescent lights hidden behind a valence mounted high on the walls. Congress Heights is the only station to have these in its escalator shafts.

Four figured this one out.

Image 4: Deanwood

I snapped the fourth photo in the mezzanine at Deanwood station. I was really taken with the play of light and shadow here when I disembarked the down escalator, so I took this picture. The unique feature is the solitary escalator penetrating the platform above. There are very few places in the system where there's just one escalator unpaired with another escalator, stair, or elevator.

At Deanwood, the platform is accessible by an elevator and two escalators. But instead of having the escalators side-by-side they're in-line. This is because the platform is a tiny bit narrower than other island platforms, and having two side-by-side escalators would make it too narrow where they land.

Five knew this was Deanwood.

Image 5: East Falls Church

The final image was a bit easier (it was put last to match the A-B-C-D-E pattern). It's East Falls Church. The station is clearly a general peak station. But it's somewhat different from the others because instead of the canopy being supported by columns along the platform, it's supported by full-height walls outside the tracks. Only Dunn Loring shares that design.

The difference from Dunn Loring is that the mezzanine at East Falls Church is under the platform, which you can tell is the case here because the escalator in the foreground is going down.

Thirteen got it right.

Next week, we're taking a break. But we'll be back in two weeks with five more photos for you to identify. Thanks for playing!

Information about contest rules, submission guidelines, and a leaderboard is available at

Think you know Metro? It's whichWMATA week 69

It's time for the sixty-ninth installment of our weekly "whichWMATA" series! Below are photos of 5 stations in the Washington Metro system. Can you identify each from its picture?

Image 1

Image 2

Image 3

Image 4

Image 5

Please have your answers in by noon on Thursday. We'll hide the comments so the early birds don't spoil the fun for the rest of you.

The answers will appear on Thursday. Good luck! Update: The answers are here.

Information about contest rules, submission guidelines, and a leaderboard is available at

Here are the answers to whichWMATA week 68

On Tuesday, we posted our sixty-eighth photo challenge to see how well you knew Metro. I took photos of five Metro stations. Here are the answers. How well did you do?

This week we got 32 guesses. Nineteen got all five. Great work!

Image 1: Wiehle Avenue

The theme this week was end-of-line stations. Many of you figured it out, and that helped you solve the quiz.

The first image shows the southern pedestrian bridge leading to Wiehle Avenue. There are a few main clues visible here: the bridge is very long, and features a box-like gallery above the column between the express and local lanes. Also, you can see the bollards separating the bus bays from the exit ramp, a feature only used at Wiehle Avenue.

Twenty-nine got this one.

Image 2: Vienna

The second image shows the platform at Vienna. There are three clues here. First, the stair-escalator combo is fairly rare, and these new stairs are distinctive. Second, you can see diagonal windows over the tracks, a feature present only at Vienna and West Falls Church. Finally, if you look very closely, you can just barely make out freeway signs down the trackway to the right.

Twenty-five knew this one.

Image 3: Shady Grove

The third image shows the east entrance to Shady Grove. The lighter colored wall around the opening is unique to Shady Grove, so it was the primary clue. Others noted the trees planted above, which indicates either a roadway or rail line runs over the tunnel between this vantage point and the Metro platform. Few stations have that sort of arrangement, but Shady Grove is one.

Twenty-two guessed correctly.

Image 4: Branch Avenue

The fourth image shows the canopy at Branch Avenue. We featured it recently in week 66, and noted that the trapezoidal blocks atop the columns were unique to this station. One additional clue that could've helped you narrow it down from the other three high peak stations is that only at Branch Avenue does the triangular skylight go all the way to the end of the roof, as opposed to stopping some distance back.

Twenty-four guessed Branch Avenue.

Image 5: Largo

The final picture shows the view up the stairs at Largo. This could have easily been any of the three Gull II stations. But the main way to solve this one was to identify the theme. Of the terminal stations, only Largo has the Gull II design.

Twenty-five managed to figure this one out.

Next Tuesday we'll have five more photos for you to identify. Thanks for playing!

Information about contest rules, submission guidelines, and a leaderboard is available at

Think you know Metro? It's whichWMATA week 68

It's time for the sixty-eighth installment of our weekly "whichWMATA" series! Below are photos of 5 stations in the Washington Metro system. Can you identify each from its picture?

Image 1

Image 2

Image 3

Image 4

Image 5

Note: This is a themed week.

Please have your answers in by noon on Thursday. We'll hide the comments so the early birds don't spoil the fun for the rest of you.

The answers will appear on Thursday. Good luck!

Information about contest rules, submission guidelines, and a leaderboard is available at

Here are the answers to whichWMATA week 67

On Tuesday, we posted our sixty-seventh photo challenge to see how well you knew Metro. I took photos of five Metro stations. Here are the answers. How well did you do?

This week we got 19 guesses. Ten got all five. Great work, Peter K, Mike B, Alex B, Justin..., FN, MZEBE, JamesDCane, Alex C, Dylan P, and Mr. Johnson!

Image 1: Twinbrook

The first image shows a view from the platform at Twinbrook. The clues here include the Hilton hotel, visible behind the train, and the Gull wing I canopy. The Gull I canopy is present at only 15 stations, so that narrows it down considerably. Many of you either recognized the Hilton or searched for it to come to a conclusion.

Fifteen got this one.

Image 2: Dunn Loring

The second image shows the platform stair/escalator bank at Dunn Loring. This part of the station was also featured in week 39.

One of the clues is the line of skylights, which are typical of the I-66 median stations. The sloped concrete roof (paralleling the escalators) at the top of the picture is also endemic to the I-66 stations. Additionally, the escalator-stair-escalator arrangement is fairly rare in the system.

One final clue is the sunlight streaming in at far right. Dunn Loring is oriented east-west, with the entrance at the west end. Peter K correctly surmised that I took this photo on the same day as the week 39 photo, with the setting sun shining down the tracks.

Twelve knew this one.

Image 3: Potomac Avenue

The third image shows the entrance to Potomac Avenue. The station's escalator bank is housed in a small plaza north of Pennsylvania Avenue, and the rowhouses in the background should have helped you figure this out. Another clue: It's also one of the stations without an entrance canopy.

Fifteen guessed correctly.

Image 4: Naylor Road

The fourth image shows Naylor Road. There are a couple of clues here. First, the segmented strip map that appears below the station name plate is the type installed on the Green Line extension to Branch Avenue. But of those stations, all are either underground or in a depressed cut, except for Naylor Road, the only elevated station.

Additionally, you can see the cloverleaf ramp from Branch Avenue onto Suitland Parkway in the background. The setting and strip map should have helped you narrow this down to Naylor Road station.

Fifteen guessed Naylor Road.

Image 5: Federal Center SW

The final image shows Federal Center SW. This entrance is one of the few under-building entrances where the escalators actually point into the sunlight (most point toward the building). The square openings above the entranceway are unique to Federal Center SW, so that should have been the lynchpin for your guess.

Eleven managed to figure this one out.

Next Tuesday we'll have five more photos for you to identify. Thanks for playing!

Information about contest rules, submission guidelines, and a leaderboard is available at

Support Us