Greater Greater Washington


Blumenauer wouldn't raise gas tax, LaHood forgets about DC residents, Gray talks transit and voting rights

At Rail~Volution Tuesday, Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood called for citizens to get involved in the ongoing transportation deadlock in Congress, but forgot that many in the audience have no voting representation. Mayor Vincent Gray, who spoke Monday, touted the city's transit investments and pushed for broader support for voting rights.

Photo by Clarence Eckerson, Jr.

Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-OR)also known as the godfather of the "rail~volution"said even he wouldn't raise the gas tax right now. "We should make some adjustments to a gas tax that hasn't increased since 1993," Blumenauer said. "Half the people think the gas tax goes up every year."

He said he'd like to see it indexed to inflation:

In an ideal world, I would not raise the gas tax this year or next year. Come out of this recession, but put in place increases that are going to occur over the next 10 years; have that revenue stream. I would borrow against the revenue stream to take advantage of record low interest rates and a bidding climate like we've never seen, fund the president's infrastructure bank to help move some of these forward, and work toward replacing the gas tax.
Blumenauer reminded the audience that his state was the first to institute a gas tax, and now Oregon is working to get rid of it and replace it with a vehicle miles traveled fee.

Bill Millar, the outgoing president of the American Public Transit Association ("on Halloween, I turn into a pumpkin!"), said that before switching to a VMT fee, Congress needs to eliminate the federal guarantee, called "equity bonus," that states will get back at least a certain percentage of what they pay in gas tax receipts. (The GAO recently found that every state actually gets back more than it puts in, thanks to infusions from the general fund, but that hasn't stopped a lot of states from complaining that they don't get their fair share.)

"States that encourage more travel get more money back [under the equity bonus system]," Millar said, "so we've got to break that cycle too, to make sure instead it's an inverse relationship and states that give people more choice, more ways to travel, get more federal aid, not less federal aid."

Millar thinks the answer is simply to raise the gas tax. And he doesn't agree that it needs to wait. After all, the average price of gas in America went up by seven cents this week, he noted. But did anybody notice? "If you told Americans that, they wouldn't like it, but hey, it's gas, what can you do?" he said.

Either way, the U.S. has got to do something to avoid running up the deficit. Congress can continue to run up an infrastructure deficit, Blumenauer said, which will cost far more in the long run. Or the country can keep spending even the meager amount it does now on transportation maintenance and the Highway Trust Fund will run dry, requiring another general fund transfer, which adds to the deficit.

Why can't Congress move forward on any path out of the current fix? Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood has been pretty open with his frustration lately. "The last election elected about 70+ new members of the House," he said at Rail~Volution. "About 30 or 40 of those people came here to do nothing. And that's what they've done."

Blumenauer noted that his first public event in Congress was a bipartisan press conference with LaHood, then a representative from Illinois. They had called for civility in Washington.

"In the days when I served with Earl and others, there was a good mix of policy and politics," LaHood said. "Unfortunately, today, the policy part has dropped off and it's all politics. It's all about the next election."

He fumbled his call to action, though. "Everyone in this room has a member of Congress; everyone has two senators," he saidmomentarily forgetting, I guess, that he was talking to hundreds of people in Washington, DC, where 600,000 residents have neither.

Just the day before, Mayor Vincent Gray had buttered up the Rail~Volution audience by talking about the Dulles rail extension and streetcars, and ended by asking the audience to push for democracy for DC so that residents there can be represented like everyone else as Congress debates the issues of the day.

For example, the jobs bill: That's what LaHood wanted everyone to call up their members of Congress about. Or passing a "five-year" [sic] transportation bill.

Bill Millar reminded the audience that transit activism isn't just about those big federal-level initiatives that get caught in big federal-level partisan gridlock. Eight cities and towns will vote on transit-related ballot initiatives in November. Millar noted that on the very same day last November when the American people voted in a new class of self-styled fiscal hawks, they also voted nearly three-to-one in favor of pro-transit measureseven when they involved taxation.

"You can't rest when you get home!" Millar exhorted Rail~Volution attendees.

They gave him a standing ovation.

Tanya Snyder is editor of Streetsblog Capitol Hill, which covers issues of national transportation policy. She previously covered Congress for Pacifica and public radio. She lives car-free in a transit-oriented and bike-friendly neighborhood of Washington, DC. 


Add a comment »

Is this how you treat your friends? Parse their words and focus on anything they say that isn't perfect? I live in DC and don't have a problem with what Lahood said. It's unfortunate we lack representation but I don't expect every federal agency head or politician to have to embed that into their talking points.

by Paul S on Oct 20, 2011 1:35 pm • linkreport

It's not about an increase in the gas tax, it is about expectations.

Promising a rise of 5 cents every year is very different than a 50 cent increase in one year.

And I suspect a lot of states have increased their rates -- multiple times -- since the last federal tax gas tax increase.

VMT is crazy. There is a space for that in 20 or 30 years. There is plenty of room before that for gas tax increases -- to where we get $5 or $6 gasoline --and where everyone drives electric cars.

by charlie on Oct 20, 2011 2:32 pm • linkreport

Totally agree with Paul S on this one.

It'll be interesting to see if an increase in the gas tax for the Highway Trust Fund also increases the amount allotted to the Mass Transit Account - 2.87 cents of every 18.2 cents taxed per gallon)

by AL on Oct 20, 2011 4:53 pm • linkreport

This country is in for a rough time if even the most bike friendly member of Congress does not want to increase the gas tax.

by Jasper on Oct 20, 2011 5:11 pm • linkreport

@Jasper--it is the middle of a recession, and the gas tax is pretty regressive. I'm in favor of increasing it, but it can wait until unemployment gets below 7.5%.

by Dan Miller on Oct 20, 2011 7:49 pm • linkreport

I'd cut LaHood some slack more than others, but I wouldn't let him off the hook entirely. He's been in the DC area for almost two decades now and regularly touts the city's advancements. He simply should know better.

by jeff on Oct 20, 2011 9:00 pm • linkreport

@ Dan Miller:I'm in favor of increasing it, but it can wait until unemployment gets below 7.5%.

So, you're not in favor of increasing the gas tax.

by Jasper on Oct 21, 2011 10:32 am • linkreport

A five or ten cent increase in the gas tax is going to be far less than market fluctations in gasoline this year. Or next.

by charlie on Oct 21, 2011 10:36 am • linkreport

@ charlie: +1

Make it a 5-10 percent gas tax and you're still way below the fluctuations.

by Jasper on Oct 22, 2011 12:15 pm • linkreport

Add a Comment

Name: (will be displayed on the comments page)

Email: (must be your real address, but will be kept private)

URL: (optional, will be displayed)

Your comment:

By submitting a comment, you agree to abide by our comment policy.
Notify me of followup comments via email. (You can also subscribe without commenting.)
Save my name and email address on this computer so I don't have to enter it next time, and so I don't have to answer the anti-spam map challenge question in the future.


Support Us