Greater Greater Washington

Pedestrians


Roads by Anacostia Metro among worst in DC for pedestrians

Narrow sidewalks, a 5-way intersection, and missing median strips and crosswalks are just some of the problems around the Anacostia Metro. A project funded by several federal agencies aims to find solutions to what EPA officials called the city's most dangerous intersections for pedestrians.


Street in front of Anacostia Metro. Photo by Old Anacostia on Flickr.

The Anacostia Metro opened in December 1991 as the southern­most Green Line Station, bunched between I-295 and Suitland Parkway. Designers expected it to be a park-and-ride commuter station. But subsequent stations in Prince George's County quickly undercut the demand for parking at Anacostia.

Meanwhile, nearly 70% of Ward 8 households don't own a car, making the design incompatible with surrounding communities.

The original design made pedestrian access an afterthought. In the two decades since, few improvements have been made to increase pedestrian safety around the station. Coming and going is perilous for the large swaths of schoolchildren and seniors in the area.

Anacostia was selected as one of 5 capital city communities across the country to participate in Greening America's Capitals, a project between the Environmental Protection Agency, US Department of Housing and Urban Development, and US Department of Transportation.

The program will "produce schematic designs and exciting illustrations intended to catalyze or complement a larger planning process for the pilot neighborhood."

The station is "badly in need of attention," according to Harriet Tregoning, Director of the DC Office of Planning, who reiterated that improvements would "complement other [ongoing] projects" in the neighborhood. The station lacks a distinctive character and, although, within short walking distance of the Anacostia River, there are no direct access paths to the waterfront.


Top: Current dangerous condition of Firth Sterling Avenue SE and Howard Road Suitland Parkway SE. Bottom: Rendering of a possible safer configuration with a refuge median. Photos by the author showing slides presented at the meeting.

To improve pedestrian safety, residents suggested footbridges, wayfinding signage, refuge medians, speed humps, and better street lighting. A slide presentation contrasted the present condition of Howard Road, Firth Sterling Avenue, and the 5-point intersection of Martin Luther King, Jr. Avenue, Howard Road, and Sheridan Road with renderings that envisioned what the future could look like.

James Magruder, a native of Ward 8 who works with Washington Parks and People, agreed that the intersection of Howard Road and Firth Sterling was in dire need of attention. "Over the years that corner has been the site of many accidents that have been fatal" to pedestrians, said Magruder.

Another way to improve safety in the area is to develop some of the many vacant properties around the station. WMATA owns one large vacant field on the other side of Howard Road, and both the Williams and Fenty administrations pushed to relocate WMATA's headquarters here, though without success.

Brenda Richardson, who works for Councilmember Marion Barry, claimed that WMATA has been unresponsive to their inquiries about the station area. In response, an official from WMATA who had been sitting in the back of the room said Metro is conducting an "initial evaluation to determine what the issues are" around safety.

Some east of the river denizens were skeptical that the studies would lead to change. "We're studied out," said one resident who attends similar meetings weekly. "Everyone's studying us to get money. Then the plans get sat on for 20 years."

"The worse case scenario is this doesn't happen," an EPA official admitted. "This only happens if all parties agree."

John Muller is a local journalist and historian. His first book, Frederick Douglass in Washington, DC: The Lion of Anacostia, was published by The History Press last year. John is now at work on Mark Twain in Washington, DC.  

Comments

Add a comment »

I agree that it is one of the worst. But I think the better picture to demonstrate how clearly unsafe it is..is one showing pedestrian access from the station to across to Barry Farms which at all times, is a freaking nightmare.

Let me see if I can figure out how to embed the google map thing.

by HogWash on Feb 17, 2012 11:17 am • linkreport


View Larger Map

by HogWash on Feb 17, 2012 11:41 am • linkreport

Pedestrians (like the ones seen here) have to cross Suitland Parkway to go either north or South of the Anacostia metro. Ironically, this is around the same area where the streetcar tracks were laid and nothing about the work there helped to increase pedestrian access/safety to the obvious transit hub...the Anacostia metro

by HogWash on Feb 17, 2012 11:49 am • linkreport

John, Quick correction, the rendering you show is the Suitland/Firth Sterling intersection, now Howard/Firth Sterling. While both have dangerous slip lanes and their share of safety issues, only Suitland has an existing median (that doesn't quite reach the crosswalk).

Also, I disagree that there hasn't been attention or prior ped safety remedies at the station. There is a recently installed Hawk signal on Howard, DDOT turned Shannon Pl. into a cul de sac (although imperfect). I think the more accurate way to describe its history is "Despite several prior rounds of spot remedies, collectively they are not sufficient to address some of the most important pedestrian safety issues which stem from the initial flawed assumption that Anacostia would be a park'n ride station."

by will on Feb 17, 2012 12:49 pm • linkreport

@Will You are right -- my error at misidentifying the intersection in the picture. With regards to the history of ped safety remedies, you said it much better than I did. Appreciate your comments.

What are some solutions you think would work?

by John M on Feb 17, 2012 1:07 pm • linkreport

Move the station to MLK & Good Hope!

by Ear to the streets on Feb 17, 2012 3:41 pm • linkreport

@Ear

The original plan from the 1968 ARS had the Anacostia station at Good Hope Road and Minnesota Avenue. The station now known as Congress Height previously called Alabama Avenue was to be located along Naylor Road south of Alabama Avenue. The present location of the station is the result of the high cost of digging the tunnels under Good Hope Road and an alignment change that Prince George's county wanted that was argued in the courts.

by Sand Box John on Feb 18, 2012 9:18 am • linkreport

I'm not familiar with the area. However, even looking at Google Maps you can see it's probably bad. Turning the 5-way intersection to a 3-way, with Sheridan Road and the east side of Howard Road removed from the intersection (and connected just to each other) would probably mitigate some of the traffic problems. In my Google Maps image, the red is either converted to green space or a pedestrian island. The yellow is dedicated right turn lanes. There is an optional dedicated right turn lane from northbound MLK to Sheridan.

by Steve K on Feb 20, 2012 2:59 am • linkreport

Let's try the graphic again.

by Steve K on Feb 20, 2012 3:06 am • linkreport

Maybe two or three years ago after a ballgame at Nationals Park my wife and I decided to walk across the Douglass Bridge to the Anacostia Metro stop (using the north entrance underneath the corner of the parking garage) instead of cramming in with everyone else at Navy Yard. We were heading to Branch Avenue to retrieve the car. We've never made that walk again. It's not an enjoyable trip at all. The pedestrian walkway on the ballpark side of the Douglass Bridge requires going way out of your way once you reach the Anacostia side of the river because of the ramp leading onto the bridge from the park. Then you walk back across those open fields on unevenly-paved roads, followed by a walk down Howard Road on a narrow sidewalk that's often littered with broken glass and the like. (I made the mistake of making this walk wearing Timberland walking sandals....never again. I feared for my feet.) I would never even remotely consider making this walk at night. Howard Road is a busy enough street, but most of the walk felt very isolated such that if anything happened to you nobody would know, and I'm not going to sugarcoat that at nighttime I'd feel very out of place walking on Howard Road as a suburban white guy.

Perhaps if they ever rebuild the Douglass Bridge they can improve the pedestrian access in this respect. The idea of providing a good alternative to the Navy Yard stop for ballpark traffic is appealing in my mind. If you remember how the entrances to the Stadium-Armory stop used to get massively backed up after Redskins games, such that lots of people used to walk to Potomac Avenue, then you get a sense of the benefit. (As it is we now drive to ballgames instead of taking the Metro because it's a lot faster and more pleasant and I found a secret spot where I can park either for free or for a maximum of about $2 for most games.)

by Rich on Feb 21, 2012 5:14 pm • linkreport

EPA's report on the project, "Greening America's Capitals: The Anacostia Metro Station Area, Washington, D.C.," is now posted at: http://epa.gov/smartgrowth/publications.htm#tech

by Melissa Kramer on Aug 8, 2012 2:43 pm • linkreport

Add a Comment

Name: (will be displayed on the comments page)

Email: (must be your real address, but will be kept private)

URL: (optional, will be displayed)

Your comment:

By submitting a comment, you agree to abide by our comment policy.
Notify me of followup comments via email. (You can also subscribe without commenting.)
Save my name and email address on this computer so I don't have to enter it next time, and so I don't have to answer the anti-spam map challenge question in the future.

or