Greater Greater Washington

Roads


cArmy Base: Fort Meade

Military bases dot the landscape all around the Capital region. This is a unique presence, as many cities in America are largely defined by the one or two military bases near their boundaries, like Fayetteville, North Carolina; Pensacola, Florida; Kileen, Texas; Norfolk and even San Diego. Washington, DC, however, is home to the entire Federal Government, so a few military bases is pocket change in comparison. Among the most prominent is a WWI-era base halfway between DC and Baltimore called Fort George G. Meade.


Photo from the Army.

Nestled at the northeast corner of the junction of the Baltimore-Washington Parkway and MD-32, Fort Meade is by far the largest single job center in the state of Maryland and, after Downtown and Tysons Corner, the third largest in the metro area, and this does not account for National Business Park, a huge complex of government contractor buildings right across the B-W Parkway. Fort Meade is home to tens of thousands of military personnel from all five branches, plus retirees. It houses several major Army units, including the Defense Information School, Defense Courier Service, and the US Army Field Band. The Environmental Protection Agency has a large facility, and let's not forget about the National Security Agency, which housed over 30,000 jobs according to James Bamford's 2000 book Body of Secrets. No doubt that number has increased in recent years. Additionally, 5,700 jobs are being relocated to Fort Meade in the Base Relocation and Closure.

The continued growth of the base is a big isssue, considering the institutional problems within the defense department when it comes to planning policy. The Pentagon, for example, sits atop two lines of Metro, yet it still has the largest surface parking lot in Arlington County. Fort Meade's total surface parking rivals (if not overtakes) FedEx Field's. This is particularly alarming considering the surface parking's negative effects on storm water runoff into the adjacent Patuxent Research Refuge (to the point where the NSA has an entire section devoted to it on its website). But the base's planning priority? Two 18 hole golf courses to "maintain soldiers' quality of life."

Surely with all these jobs, thousands of residents, and an explosion of growth in the near future, there must be some kind of transit node on the base, right? Not really.

The base is served by a single bus, a 24-seater that runs only twice in the morning and twice in the evening and serves only portions of the city of Laurel to the NSA's main gate. Various agencies on the base offer shuttles that run a few times a day from the Odenton and Savage MARC stations, which are two and five miles from the NSA main gate, respectively, and each three miles from the nearest regular base gate. It is literally illegal to walk any of those routes, as they are largely along MD-32, a freeway of interstate standards. Even servicemen living on base are likely to commute by car, as the base is so spread out that it is a long walk from any of the housing to any of the jobs on post, including almost all of the shopping and recreation amenities.

The first thing I did when I got stationed at Fort Meade? Buy a car. Sure, I wanted a car to go home and visit my family regularly. But I would not have been able to attend my morning physical training without a car. And this was when I lived in the battalion barracks!

So what do you care about a base 20 miles outside of DC? Consider that a traffic nightmare reaching the base would have a major impact on transportation between Baltimore and Washington. The economic impacts of the resulting disconnect between the two cities could be drastic. Ryan Avent considered the positive impacts that a high speed rail between DC and Baltimore would provide. Clogging the highways between the two cities would likely have the opposite effect.

I have often considered Fort Meade an ideal place for the Baltimore and Washington rail systems to meet. I know many detractors consider it wasteful to run the system all the way out to Fort Meade. But smaller jobs centers in Chantilly and Reston, similarly unserved by transit currently will be getting Silver Line service within a decade. And transportation implications in northwestern Fairfax County do not affect passage between two major cities. Other bases involved in the BRAC, such as Andrews AFB, Bolling AFB, Fort Belvoir, and Bethesda Naval Medical Center, have all had plenty of proposals thrown around to improve transit access to the bases (in some cases, like Bolling and Bethesda Naval, increasing existing transit efficiency). Fort Meade has not, despite the unique opportunity of potentially being able to serve the base by two major cities' transit systems. To alleviate traffic at enormous (50,000+) job centers, connector shuttles from commuter rails (i.e. a necessary modal shift) just won't do the trick. Perhaps for a Metro station, the NSA could donate some of it's 900+ acres of parking.

But today, long before ground will ever be broken on any kind of rail connections, wouldn't it at least be appropriate for Fort Meade to receive some sort of express bus service from Greenbelt Metro? Perhaps more regular service from towns like Columbia, Laurel, Odenton and Annapolis? A bus system for the base itself so that a young GI doesn't have to waste his first few paychecks on a new car?

It blows my mind that 18 year old privates are not allowed to drink alcohol, but they are expected to be mature enough to finance, purchase, insure, and properly operate their own heavy machinery, which they may legally store on base free of charge. Shame on Army bases across the country, but particularly Fort Meade, which has the resources nearby to outgrow ridiculous and deleterious planning policies. For a service known for moving on foot, the Army's bases certainly don't embrace any mode of transportation beyond the car.

Dave Murphy is a Geographic Analyst for the Department of Defense and a US Army veteran. He is also a part time bouncer. He was born in Foggy Bottom and is a lifelong resident of the DC area. He currently resides in the Eckington neighborhood of Northeast. 

Comments

Add a comment »

Yes Chantilly may be unserved by mass transit. Reston, however is linked to WFC by 5 bus lines. For city dwellers there are 4 full size busess from WFC to Reston per hour during rush hours on the 951 and 951. If you are going Reston Town center on the 505 there are another 4 buses per hour leaving from WFC. The transit time is a very reliable 20 minutes.

Reston does not have a train station, so it is unserved in that respect, but you don't need a car to get there. You might, however, need a car to get around after you get there (like you will also need when the silver line is finished).

Back to your main point, as a veteran, I can tell you that living on a military installation without a car was crap. Excluding, of course, the Presidio, which isn't a base anymore anyway.

By the way, at least when I was "in", 18 year olds could drink on base.

by Tom on Nov 6, 2008 1:05 pm • linkreport

Dave-

I agree with your sentiment and agree that the Fort Meade area is a logical stop along a Washington - Baltimore mass transit connector. Problem is that the issue of mass transit has no traction among the people who would make such decisions on Fort Meade. They aren't going to spend money on transportation options when they are not funded to do so. They are funded to perform military operations, intelligence support, and to care and feed their soldiers. Not to reduce traffic on state highways or to solve WMATA, DDOT, Maryland DOT, or U.S. DOT problems.

Also, they will always justify the need for cars on base (rather than mass transit) because of the nature of shift and weekeend work. Watchstanders need to be able to come and go at times when Metro isn't running. That is, in many ways, an excuse rather than a justification. But when I was a watchstander at the Pentagon I was told I needed a parking pass since I had to come in at off-hours...and if you get a parking pass you don't get Metro subsidies so you can imagine I chose to drive. No commander wants a soldier saying they can't come to work on a weekend because the bus wasn't running. They overcompensate so they encourage people to drive to have the flexibility to come and go at all hours.

by Andrew C on Nov 6, 2008 3:44 pm • linkreport

The bummer is that Ft. Meade used to be a major stop on the old BW&A interurban (now defunct). "Camp Meade was established in the area roughly bounded by the B&O Washington Branch on the west, the Pennsylvania Railroad on the east, and the South Shore Line of the WB&A to the south. The installation was supposed to be a temporary facility, used only for the duration of the war (it is still in use today). The WB&A saw record traffic during this time as a result of freight and passenger service to the camp. In 1918, the railroad was running as many as 84 special trains a day."

But alas, that line is gone. Still it'd be easy to connect the base to the two existing lines via MARC rail using the old rail bed (much of which still exists) between Annapolis Junction (aka Savage) and Odenton. They should also build a parallel bike trail and give soldiers free bikes.

by David C on Nov 6, 2008 5:53 pm • linkreport

Many, many young and/or new DoD employees in the Ft. Meade area are dismayed at the lack of reliable mass transit and have raised their voices on internal blogs and discussion groups.

by A concerned DoD employee on Nov 6, 2008 8:36 pm • linkreport

Andrew C- I agree that your theories lot to do with the institutional lack of planning on DoD properties, however I think it extends beyond just that.

The simple fact that military base housing is laid out in such an illogical, uneconomical, space wasting manner for no good reason other than the fact that it is the suburban status quo is indicative of a problem that transcends a need for on-call personnel and local transportation funding.

Also, the on-call requirement could be fixed by running Metro 24 hours, something that ought to be done for a number of reasons. The amount of parking at the Pentagon is ludicrous compared to the number of people that would need late night or weekend access to the facility. Metro runs 17 hours a day, and the Pentagon is served by two lines that both run through Maryland, DC, and Virginia. Fort Meade, on the other hand, is running out of places to pave, as they have no alternative other than a handful of feeble vanpools and some half-assed shuttle services.

by Dave Murphy on Nov 7, 2008 1:07 am • linkreport

Dave: You can't run metro 24 hours. We don't have the track system for it. WMATA needs the time between closing and opening to perform maintenance or repairs.

NYC can do it because some lines have more than two-way track.

by Michael P on Nov 7, 2008 6:18 am • linkreport

Relating to Tom's comment: first thing most of my junior sailors want to do when they check into a command is they want to move out of the barracks as soon as possible, especially the older ones who didn't join the Navy right out of high school.

Andrew C makes a good point: as a general rule, transportation concerns to/from base do have interest with senior base leadership (at least on the Navy side). But like Andrew said, we're not funded to implement anything except specific on-base items and low-cost items....we're funded mainly to do our job, and not much else.

And I'll be the first to tell you (well the second behind Andrew) that in the military, operational flexibility will trump transportation concerns *ANY DAY*. If you're needed at the command at 2am...well you'd better be there by 2am...bottom line. And the onus is on you to get there. Metro is great for normal dayworking if you live and/or work near the line. But it can't solve all of the transportation issues. Nor can it run 24/7, as Michael noted.

by Froggie on Nov 8, 2008 7:29 am • linkreport

Add a Comment

Name: (will be displayed on the comments page)

Email: (must be your real address, but will be kept private)

URL: (optional, will be displayed)

Your comment:

By submitting a comment, you agree to abide by our comment policy.
Notify me of followup comments via email. (You can also subscribe without commenting.)
Save my name and email address on this computer so I don't have to enter it next time, and so I don't have to answer the anti-spam map challenge question in the future.

or