Greater Greater Washington

Arts


Residents want to make police station into arts center

Next year, the Montgomery County police department's Third District station will move to a new facility in White Oak, leaving their current building at Sligo Avenue and Grove Street in downtown Silver Spring. While some neighbors worried that the site would be redeveloped as housing, resident Karen Roper saw a chance to bring local artists together.


The police station today. Photo by the author.

Roper, who lives in adjacent East Silver Spring and sits on the board of their civic association, has long been active in local affairs. When the police announced their move in 2009, she began exploring ways to repurpose it with the help of her neighbors Steve Knight, his wife Karen Burditt, and Dan Morales, all architects.

"I realized ... that we needed to start earlier on getting behind things that we wanted," she says. "Knowing that the police station was going to move, I started talking to the neighbors around it."

Many of those neighbors were artists who lacked space to work. "[They] have outgrown working in their attics or basements and they're ready to move to something bigger or more serious," says Knight.

Roper worries that new development would make downtown Silver Spring "an audience district" by pushing them out. "We're an arts district that has no space for artists," says Roper. "East Silver Spring is full of artists. That's who we've always been."


The Gateway Arts Center in Brentwood. Photo by Anne Marchand on Flickr.

One of those artists, Laurie Breen, located her studio in the Gateway Arts Center in Brentwood, which opened two years ago in a former government surplus warehouse. Run by the Gateway Community Development Corporation and the Prince George's County Department of Parks and Recreation, the center holds classes, has two galleries, along with studios for 13 artists.

Roper wanted to create a place like that in Silver Spring. Her group envisions turning the 1960's-era police station into the Station Arts Center, a place where local artists can make and display their work and residents take classes. The parking lot in back would be turned into a community garden with 44 plots and "plenty of parking," while the front lawn would become an outdoor hangout like "the Turf," the temporary green that stood where Veterans Plaza is today.

The station is located between downtown's high-rises and the porch-fronted bungalows of East Silver Spring, and both Roper and Knight refer to it as a good place for a "transition" or "buffer" between the two while reinforcing the community's character. A thousand units will be built in Fenton Village over the next few years, says Roper, but "there's no green space, there's no community gardens, and there's no space for artists."

Knight and Burditt introduced the Station Arts Center concept in a column for the Silver Spring Voice. To "prove a need and a desire" for the project, the group is circulating a petition.

Civic groups and the Silver Spring Citizens Advisory Board have also been receptive. "When I pitched the idea of an arts center and community garden, people loved it," Roper says, adding that David Dise, director of the county's Department of General Services, called it the "best proposal he'd ever heard for Silver Spring."

Roper, Knight and Morales took a quick tour of the police station and found it wouldn't take much to turn it into an arts center.

"I think you could go in there on Day 1 and have a fairly reasonable artist space," says Knight, noting that the building and its mechanical systems were in good repair, but could be reconfigured easily. "I don't think there's anything sacred [architecturally] about the building. It provides a pretty good blank slate to start with." There are also more unusual features, like an underground shooting range beneath the parking lot, which Roper says would make a "cool darkroom" for photographers.

There are some issues, namely a lack of natural light. But "if the resources presented themselves," Knight says, "it wouldn't be really impinging the building's structural integrity if you wanted to punch some more windows into it."

Roper's excited about the building's aesthetic qualities. "The police station is funky and square and 60's in look ... it lends itself well to an arts center," she says.

The Parks Department is "extremely enthusiastic" about the community garden, she adds, because the site is already publicly owned and fenced off, requiring little additional work. Knight notes that there was a "pretty positive response" to one at Fenton Street Park, two blocks away.

Meanwhile, the lawn in front of the police station would become a "front yard" that Knight compares to "the Turf." It would be a "more casual outdoor space for people where you can just walk out, lay out a beach towel and get a tan."

"We're not going to blanket the police station in Astroturf," he jokes.

Though the design isn't finished, Roper estimates that it will cost $750,000 to renovate the police station. She is currently looking for a nonprofit group to operate the arts center, which would sustain itself by renting between 25 and 50 studios to working artists, offering classes to the public and some sort of "retail place."

"All we need from the county is a short-term lease," says Roper. "We don't need any funds from them."

Will the Station Arts Center plan work? We'll look at it in more detail tomorrow, along with one change I think could make it better.

A planner and architect by training, Dan Reed is interested in suburban retrofits. Dan works for the Friends of White Flint, writes his own blog, Just Up the Pike, and serves as the Land Use Chair for the Action Committee for Transit. Dan lives in Silver Spring. 

Comments

Add a comment »

Intriguing idea. I live very close to this site and have always envisioned it being torn down since it completely misuses the land (relatively small building surrounded on 3 sides by large parking lots and set back very far from the street). I still think I'd prefer it demoed for an EYA-style townhome development (the perfect "buffer," in my mind), but an arts center/creative reuse of all the underutilized land surrounding the building sounds great too. I just worry that no one will use the grass in front of the building and that a fenced off community garden isn't that big of an upgrade over a fenced off parking lot.

by jag on May 15, 2012 10:50 am • linkreport

We can do housing and an arts center right? Sort of like what they do in Lorton but with housing or the new areas in old town fairfax (though part of that is just temporary from the outset until the commercial space could be filled).

by Canaan on May 15, 2012 10:58 am • linkreport

umm, I highly recommend having a cultural plan/facilities plan for the county/area. Is there a formal plan for the Silver Spring Arts & Entertainment district? (I meant to check, I never did.) It's a good idea, maybe, but needs to be part of a broader milieu to be effective, with a specific capacity development mission.

The Gateway center is cool, but most of the events are more community building focused than arts development focused, not along the lines of my paper:

- http://urbanplacesandspaces.blogspot.com/2012/04/arts-artistic-production-and-culture.html

although Gateway has a great arts plan, the issue is that they didn't adequately address the arts as production side, and their isn't enough density to support successful arts consumption. (Although I haven't been to Hyattsville post-Busboys and Poets.)

by Richard Layman on May 15, 2012 11:28 am • linkreport

Is art the driving reason for opposing housing in this area? This seems like an excellent spot for new housing.

http://g.co/maps/g7nyt

by Cassidy on May 15, 2012 11:30 am • linkreport

I don't think we need more arts space in Silver Spring. This is just an NIMBY effort to prevent needed development. Not saying we need a high rise, but silver spring needs more diverse housing options such as reasonably priced townhouses. This would bring more life to a corner of downtown that needs more residents and business

by Brian on May 15, 2012 1:06 pm • linkreport

I don't think we need more arts space in Silver Spring

Is there so much arts space in Silver Spring that this would create a glut?

I'm always skeptical of "community spaces" and the like, but Silver Spring definitely needs some spaces that are more of a middle ground between "high rise residence" and "designated shopping and dining area, after which you must leave."

My only issue is that Silver Spring doesn't do "organic" well. I can picture to director of this facility barking at patrons milling about "THIS IS THE PLACE WHERE YOU WILL DO ART FROM NOW UNTIL 6:30PM!"

by JustMe on May 15, 2012 1:11 pm • linkreport

There is the pyramid Atlantic on Georgia and there are are arts facilities in Takoma (I'm pretty sure). I also agree that forcing an arts center seems forced. It's not like there are rouge artists setting up potting wheels on Fenton throwing cray at motorists demanding a space to work. It's a really large space to be devoted to a small, niche interest group. An arts space is better suited for one of those auto repair buildings off Georgia near the CSX bridge

by Brian on May 15, 2012 1:38 pm • linkreport

The East Silver Spring Citizens Association have been supporting NIMBY efforts for more than 40 years. Needless to say, ESSCA supports making not so old buildings historic, like First Baptist Church in downtown Silver Spring.

The police station should be razed before ESSCA decides to make it a historic building worth preserving.

I would like to see large houses with backyards built. This would be a buffer to what is going on in the Central Business District of Downtown Silver Spring.

by Who Dat? on May 16, 2012 8:04 am • linkreport

omg jag youre here, shucks.

@ who dat? I AGREE. there is pyramid atlantic on georgia ave/ripley. i too wanta artists to have affordable housing while they create, but I'd rather have that lot me made in 100% affordable housing. Not the normal moco where they build houses or townhouses and just 2 are MPDU, I want all the houses on ss @ grove to be affordable. It is ridiculously expensive to live in dt ss.

by lilkunta on May 16, 2012 6:28 pm • linkreport

Add a Comment

Name: (will be displayed on the comments page)

Email: (must be your real address, but will be kept private)

URL: (optional, will be displayed)

Your comment:

By submitting a comment, you agree to abide by our comment policy.
Notify me of followup comments via email. (You can also subscribe without commenting.)
Save my name and email address on this computer so I don't have to enter it next time, and so I don't have to answer the anti-spam map challenge question in the future.

or