Google Maps loses transit icons
Google Maps has gotten another makeover, and this one isn't exactly an improvement. At most zoom levels, transit station icons have vanished from satellite view. This makes it difficult for users to find transit stops or see other stations in context. Freeway labels, of course, are omnipresent.
Metro station icons do still appear on "map" view as they used to. But for people looking at "satellite" view, finding subway stops just got a lot harder.
Even turning on the "transit" layer doesn't help. This layer isn't available in Washington, but in other cities, like New York, where it is available, it turns on rail lines but not rail stations.
If you zoom in far enough, you will eventually see the station icon. But at that zoom level, you really already need to know where the station is in order to find it.Even entering the address for the Gallery Place station, at 630 H Street NW, isn't enough to see the icon, because the default zoom level for seeing addresses is too far out.
In fact, this is the zoom level where the different galleries in the
National Gallery of Art National Portrait Gallery/American Art Museum appear. We've zoomed in so far that we can tell that art about the Civil War is in the northeast corner of the building. And that's the first zoom level where we can see that there's a Metro station across the street.
But at this zoom level, the map is only about a block tall. It's nearly impossible to see the city in context. Where are other stations? Is a different stop more convenient?
Transit stations are a fundamental thing to show on maps. For those already taking transit, it helps them know where they can find the station. For those who haven't decided on a mode, it might make them think, "hey, there's a Metro stop across the street, maybe we can take the train."
For years, Google Maps has set a very high bar by providing excellent interactive maps. But this change is a huge step backwards for transit users.
Clearly, the designers have lost sight of where transit information needs to appear in the hierarchy of map data. (Hint: it's much more important than the location of Civil War art in the
National Gallery Portrait Gallery).
Google should at least revise their satellite view so that transit station icons appear at the same zoom levels as they do in "map" view.
- Hogan stalls on the Purple Line, calls it too expensive
- Ask GGW: What's the point of bike sharrows?
- Fairfax is getting 22 new bike lanes in 2015
- "Expressing" trains helps Metro recover from delays
- CaBi's phone app could enlist riders to rebalance bikes
- Federal review pushes the Kennedy Center's new buildings to dry land
- The guy who invented the mall hated cars