Greater Greater Washington

Posts about Poverty

Sustainability


Support local charities this holiday season

The season of giving is upon us, and many of us make meaningful contributions to charitable organizations at this time of the year. When thinking about what groups to support, please consider helping out some of our local nonprofits which work to improve the lives of people in our region and create better communities.


Photo by Mindful One on Flickr.

Here are a few nonprofits which our contributors listed as some of their favorites:

The Coalition for Smarter Growth: There is one organization in this region which advocates for all of the issues we discuss on this blog, including smart growth, transit, affordable housing policies, and bridging the east-west divide.

CSG advocates for policies in many of the parts of the region where they are most needed, from Loudoun to Prince George's, and has been featured multiple times in the Catalogue for Philanthropy.

A movement is most effective when blogs, traditional nonprofits, and elected officials work together to promote ideas in concert. The Coalition for Smarter Growth is working every day to turn what we believe in and discuss here on the blog into reality.

They're a small organization (4 full-time staff) and need our support, especially in this tough economic time, to continue doing their great work and to do even more. Plus, for the month of December, other donors will match every dollar you give to CSG.

Human services: Help those most in need this year with basic food, shelter, and more. This is especially important now with a bad economy, widespread unemployment, and governments cutting back on vital services. Direct service groups like Bread for the City and So Others Might Eat provide food, clothing, medical care, legal counseling, job training and more to the most needy.

The Capital Area Food Bank provides most of the food that the direct service organizations distribute. And DC Central Kitchen turns unused food from area businesses into meals for the needy, and trains unemployed people for culinary careers.

N Street Village helps homeless women find housing, get medical and mental health care, and job training; their center on 14th Street replaced an ugly parking lot and has become an anchor for more growth on its part of 14th Street. Charlie's Place helps homeless people with food, clothing and job training. AMEN gives emergency financial assistance to Arlington residents in crisis.

Advocacy membership organizations: Many nonprofit advocacy groups are structured as membership organizations. Being a member supports their work and sometimes comes with a few extra bonuses as well. Consider joining the Washington Area Bicyclist Association, and Maryland's Action Committee for Transit. The DC Sierra Club provided much of the driving force behind streetcars. And of course, if you think DC residents should have voting rights like all other Americans, join DC Vote.

Environmental groups: Sprawl constantly threatens our natural resources and, by extension, the quality of our drinking water, recreational opportunities, and more. Some of the many local groups working are the DC, Virginia, and Maryland Sierra Clubs, the Anacostia Watershed Society, Friends of Rock Creek's Environment, Anacostia Riverkeeper, Potomac Riverkeeper, and more. Casey Trees plants and nurtures street trees to help all neighborhoods develop a healthy tree canopy.

Education and mentoring: There are so many worthy education nonprofits it's not possible to do them justice here, but here are just a few to start with: For Love of Children connects underprivileged children with one on one volunteer tutors; they're looking for more volunteers as well as funding. College and Career Connections works in Ward 7 to encourage youth to stay motivated in school and go to college, which are key to success in the modern world. And Big Brothers Big Sisters of the National Capital Area has made a difference in so many children's lives.

Food security and urban farming: People struggling with hunger and homelessness aren't the only ones who need help with food. All children need healthy meals which are often difficult for poor families to afford. Urban farms and nutrition programs seek to make more fresh food available to poor neighborhoods.

Consider supporting the DC Farm to School Network, which gets healthy, local, and sustainable food to DC schoolchildren; Common Good City Farm, an urban farm and education center growing food for low-income residents; The Farm at Walker Jones is building a farm in the H Street area for kids to learn about food and to provide it to them and needy neighbors.

Your local aging in place "village": A number of neighborhoods have "village" associations which help senior citizens remain in their homes by providing assistance with illnesses and disabilities, small home maintenance tasks, and connections to community activities. A diversity of ages is healthy and important for every neighborhood.

There are villages in Capitol Hill, Dupont Circle, Kalorama, Palisades, Chevy Chase, and more. Also, Iona Senior Center not only provides services for the elderly but helped fund the Connecticut Avenue Pedestrian Action program to make upper Connecticut safer.

Others in the Catalogue for Philanthropy: This annual publication showcases valuable, small, effective nonprofits in the DC metropolitan area around sustainability, education, human services and more. It's a great way to find out about organizations worth supporting that you might not otherwise know about.

What other local and regional organizations do you support?

Poverty


Social supports, not time limits, will reduce poverty

Marion Barry is right: generational poverty endangers communities and families. However, enforcing a time limit for welfare benefits is not the way to build strong communities or support families.


Photo by wallyg on Flickr.

Councilmembers Marion Barry (Ward 8) and Yvette Alexander (Ward 7) recently introduced a bill to limit Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (also known as TANF and hereafter referred to as welfare) recipients to 60 months of welfare benefits.

After those 60 months are up, families would also be ineligible for other public benefits such as Medicaid, child care subsides, or food stamps.

It's a lot easier to blame the victim than to take the time and resources to fix the problem. Mr. Barry told the Washington Times that one of his neighbors gets "$400 or $500 worth of food stamps but won't get up in the morning and fix breakfast" for her children.

Yes, there are differences in parenting styles by social class, but to assume that low-income parents are less caring, concerned, or invested, or unskilled caregivers is not true and unfair. If anything truly puts families and children at a disadvantage, it is growing up in poor neighborhoods without access to jobs, good schools, or child care providers.

Barry and Alexander's proposed legislation also fails to understand the dynamics of welfare usage. Most families do not intend to use welfare as their only source of income, but rely on welfare to make ends meet. Instead, most families that enter welfare exit relatively quickly to take low-paying jobs. Families able to maintain full-time, year-round work are much better off than before.

Others, however, end up returning to welfare. Not surprisingly, the most vulnerable are single mothers with little work experience or education. The wealth of research done since the 1996 welfare reform act indicate that there are numerous barriers that may affect a recipient's ability to transition from welfare to work, including physical disabilities or health limitations, availability of child care, mental health problems, health of behavioral problems of children, substance abuse, domestic violence, involvement with the child welfare system, housing instability, low basic skills, and learning disabilities.

Similar to the nation, welfare and food stamp usage in the District has fluctuated over the last ten years. The number of individuals on welfare was 46,576 in 2000, fell to a low of 42,300 in 2008, and rose to 45,136 in 2009. Since 2000, food stamp usage has increased by more than 20,000 individuals, from 80,510 in 2000 to 107,618 in 2009. It is clear that welfare and food stamp usage have gone up recently because of the recession, not an increase in long-term users trying to abuse the system.

Without supports, the families that Barry aims to help won't be able to overcome a multitude of barriers. Just like how education loans/grants, mortgage tax credits, etc., help middle class families achieve a higher standard of living, social support programs like welfare, food stamps, and child care subsidies present a potential solution for low-income families.

Instead of placing limits on welfare, the DC council should support the TANF Opportunities and Accountability Act of 2010 sponsored by Tommy Wells (Ward 6) and Michael Brown (at-large). The bill would invest in job training and educational programs as well as develop a better system to track welfare recipients in order to better understand when and why families enter and exit social programs.

The welfare system is far from perfect, but as the District faces continued economic turmoil brought on by the recession, this is not the time to limit access to important social safety nets. District food banks, shelters, and other social services are already strained and woefully unprepared to face coming economic hardships as the economy tries to build itself back up. Families that have not been able to leave welfare are some of the most disadvantaged families without any means of support other than social programs.

If Barry and Alexander are serious about reducing poverty and thus reducing welfare usage, they must propose more innovative policies with a multi-pronged approach that involves families, neighborhoods, educators, and employers.

Development


Prince George's housing challenges call for new leadership

Recently, the Coalition for Smarter Growth issued a call to the new county executive of Prince George's: fix the Housing Department. It's a tall order, but a vital one.


Photo by Marit & Toomas Hinnosaar on Flickr.

Nearly half of Prince George's households spend more on housing than they can afford. That statistic becomes even more stark when we note that the county has returned millions of dollars in federal funding that could have helped. At the same time, there is little vision about how to assist households in the future.

This is both a challenge and an opportunity. The next County Executive has it within his power to make addressing residents' housing needs a priority and create a more effective Housing Department.

In our latest report, Building Stronger Communities, we outlined both common sense solutions and innovative strategies to address this challenge, which we hope will inspire the new leaders in Prince George's County. We released this report in conjunction with our partner, Partnership for Renewal in Southern and Central Maryland (PRISCM).

Rev. Dr. Michael C. Turner, Sr., president of PRISCM and Pastor of the Miracle Center of the Faith Missionary Baptist Church in Capitol Heights has seen these challenge first hand in his congregation.

"We need leadership from a new County Executive and a new Director of Housing. While the County gives back unspent money to the federal government, many of our congregants cannot find a decent apartment to rent or a home they can afford to buy. Now is the time to transform how we meet the housing needs of our community," he said.


Source: Prince George's County FY 2011-2015 Consolidated Plan

Our report, Building Stronger Communities, provides detailed findings and recommendations aimed at transforming the County's housing programs. We encourage the adoption of national best practices to meet the needs of Prince George's families struggling with high housing costs, poor housing conditions and other challenges. Despite the challenges highlighted in the assessment, the incoming administration offers hope for new leadership.

The Democratic nominee for County Executive, Rushern Baker, is running unopposed for the general election and the presumed County Executive-elect. During Baker's campaign, he frequently spoke about the need to focus development around the county's 15 largely undeveloped Metro stations and address residents' need for affordable housing. This is a hopeful sign for a county with so much unrealized potential.

The report provides a detailed assessment of the data and key challenges to existing housing programs. While residents in all jurisdictions face major housing affordability challenges, the statistics for Prince George's are stark:

  • 46 percent of Prince George's households pay more than 30 percent of their income in housing, which is considered unaffordable by US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), compared to the D.C. region's average of 38 percent;
  • By the end of 2009, the county counted 45,300 troubled home loans;
  • Some 40 percent of renters cannot afford the median monthly rent of $1,131.
Boosting residents' incomes with increased local employment growth, improved education and training are part of the equation to helping families avoid paying more than they can afford for housing. Making housing more affordable to struggling families is also an important part of the solution. The county, however, has been beset by poorly performing housing assistance programs and weak leadership. According to HUD and an independent auditor's assessment, ineffective Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD) program management has plagued the County:
  • In winter of 2010, the County returned over $2 million in unspent HOME grant money to HUD;
  • The County's FY 2010 allocation of HOME funds was already reduced by $2.2 million because of previous shortcomings within DHCD to spend allotted funds;
  • Prince George's County in the 17th percentile nationwide in program performance for HOME grant funds;
  • In spring of 2010, the County almost lost $2.8 million in Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds and was warned by HUD that it had failed to spend down funds in time for three consecutive years.
The County does not provide any of its own resources to leverage federal and state housing assistance. Given the substantial need, and diminishing resources, residents are looking to the incoming County Executive to fix the troubled agency and make quality housing for moderate and low income Prince George's families a higher priority.

Despite the poor record of DHCD, the County recently showed outstanding success. A one-time grant from the federal Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP) of $10.8 million was given to the County to address the home foreclosure crisis. The County's NSP effort has been well administered and has met its goals of assisting over 600 households in purchasing foreclosed homes. NSP's success demonstrates that the County has the talent to execute a federally-funded program successfully when the outcomes of the program are given enough priority.

Our report outlines ways to improve DHCD's performance and more broadly address Prince George's residents' housing needs through new public policy actions:

  1. Create a comprehensive strategy that identifies housing needs across a range of households (including income, size and composition), audits existing capacity to meet those housing needs, and strategizes with a diverse set of public and private sector stakeholders to make recommendations to fill gaps in capacity and resources.
  2. Build capacity in the Department of Housing and Community Development to accomplish the County's housing goals by cultivating agency leadership and staff that demonstrate expertise in housing finance, effectively administering federal and state housing resources, and aggressively managing the County's interest in development deals.
  3. Build capacity among small local nonprofits to help meet the County's housing goals by establishing a mentoring program between these nonprofits and high capacity housing development organizations. These partnerships could produce County-supported demonstration projects that would improve the County's housing stock while increasing the capacity of the smaller nonprofits.
  4. Improve the existing housing stock by efficiently utilizing existing resources like HOME, CDBG, and state tax credits; establishing new, locally-funded resources like a housing trust fund and an acquisition fund; and using land use and zoning tools to promote mixed-income development.
  5. Establish housing policies and processes that support development projects that fit the County's larger goals, are competitively selected, meet stringent underwriting requirements and are a good investment given the time and resources required.
  6. Demonstrate political willingness to support and invest in a diverse range of housing options by aggressively backing DHCD to meet the county's housing needs and soliciting participation from industry investors, policy experts and non-profit developers through advisory committees and project review panels.

    Economic development and household wealth are built on the foundation of stable families and communities. The County has many opportunities to strengthen the economic base of moderate and low-income households who need quality housing that won't place excessive strain on their family budgets. Leadership at the highest levels is needed to create a comprehensive vision, goals and effective administrative procedures to execute programs.

    Drawing in the contributions of stakeholders outside of government, the new administration has the opportunity to transform the County' approach to addressing the housing needs of its residents and help more families enjoy the stability of decent, quality housing they can afford.

    Cheryl Cort is the Policy Director for the Coalition for Smarter Growth.

Poverty


Helping the homeless requires compassion

Washington, DC is a tale of two cities, one for the powerful and the other for the powerless. From the front steps of Saint Aloysius Church you can look to your right and see the US Capitol Dome and then look to your left to see one of the poorest zip codes in the District.


Photo by Ed Yourdon on Flickr.

Closing the gap between the realities of wealth and power on one hand and dire need on the other is a task for caring people and especially an imperative of my faith.

The Father McKenna Center, where I work, carries on the work of the late Fr. Horace B. McKenna who was known as the "priest to the poor". Horace McKenna used to say that his role was to hang on to people until help came. Our role is similar to that. We help the poor and homeless. We serve both men and women.

There is no doubt that the recession has had a great impact on the poor. A year or so ago, 143 households came to the McKenna Center each month seeking food from our pantry. Our "customers," if you will, were often mothers with children and elderly men and women from the neighborhood. At present we are seeing about 188 households coming for food. Five years ago, we saw 68 men per day at our daytime drop in center. For the last three years, the number has been over 100 men per day.

When the door opens on a weekday morning at 8 AM and our guests sign in we hope that our welcome sends a message to the men that we care about them. Throughout their stay with us they will hear us urge them to take a positive step in their lives to deal with their physical and mental health, look for work or improve their education and break the hold that alcohol and drugs have on so many homeless men.

It is relatively easy to provide a bowl of cereal in the morning and lunch at noon, to wash a man's clothes and provide him with a shower. The more difficult task is to sensitively inquire about why a man is homeless, what can we do to help him overcome his situation and what can he do for himself that will move him forward. The more interventions we do with individual homeless men the more the mental health needs of the homeless population become apparent. It is not that homeless men are crazy but that they are in many cases deeply depressed and resigned to the homeless deathstyle.

The messages we try to give our guests do not come in a vacuum. They are receiving many messages every day and our message is only one of them. What does it say to a homeless man who sleeps at the 801 East Shelter at Saint Elizabeth's when he realizes that there is one case manager at 801 for all 380 men who sleep there? It is hard to imagine that it says, "We care about you". Placing shelters far outside the mainstream of the city tells the homeless that we want them to go away.

Poverty is at the core of the homeless problem, a most complex problem. All too often we hear homeless men say that they never knew their fathers. They often had one strike against them before they could learn to talk. They often came to value the quick buck over the pains and sorrows of education. The allure of the quick buck got them involved in drugs that often led to prison. Many suffer from obvious mental illness while most suffer from mental illness that is not so obvious.

There is no simple one size fits all solution to homelessness but a solution begins with compassion that literally means "to suffer with". We can do better by the homeless and the homeless can do better for themselves so we have to work together.

Tom Howarth is the Director of The Father McKenna Center. Cross-posted at Defeat Poverty DC.

Government


Why can't Calvin fly?

At age 59, Calvin Moore has job certifications several inches thickdriving, telecommunications, tires, Department of Transportation, etc. You name it; odds are Calvin knows how to do it.


Photo by black_eyes on Flickr.

If you've seen a patched pothole in Virginia or DC, there's a good chance Calvin filled it. Yet Calvin has been out of work for almost two years. In fact, Calvin has had a lot of intermittent work experiences during his life.

"I'm like a plane trying to take off. Up a little bit and scooter back down. Up a little bit and scooter back down," he says.

His current unemployment isn't for lack of trying either. He notes that he's applied for "over 42 jobs and was turned down for all of them." For Calvin, work has been difficult to get because of health problems and a decades-old criminal record.

Most recently, Calvin was a foreman and fleet manager at a tire warehouse, moved on, got his CDL, and applied at another tire company where he tore his meniscus in his left knee. A tire shipment had arrived and Calvin was helping unload tires off a truck. The driver was in a hurry because they had several other deliveries to make. As Calvin tells it, "I had to chase a few tires down that rolled off the palette. I ran laterally and stepped through the palette and tore up my knee." The knee didn't heal right after surgery.

Then Calvin got in a car accident this past February. "I was rear ended and couldn't accept work because of an injured back as a result of the accident."

He worked the tire job after suffering health problems while filling potholes on a road construction crew. "I got asthma due to the asphalt fumes while working for the DDOT. I kept getting sick, weak to the point that I couldn't pick up the shovel with the asphalt." They fired him within a few weeks of the end of his one-year probationary period.

"I really do enjoy seeing the potholes along the roads that I had fixed down in Virginia and throughout the District."

The biggest obstacle for Calvin, however, has been his old criminal record. As a kid, Calvin was attracted to the fast life. "I was fascinated by the young guys driving Cadillacs, going to dances with alligator shoes, getting girls." He wanted that life, so as an adolescent, "I went wild."

"I didn't have to go that route. I had good parents. I had a job. I wouldn't tell my friends I had a job, but I would go out at night and then go to work the next morning."

His lifestyle caught up with him when he was arrested for armed robbery in 1973. Calvin maintains his innocence for this particular crime, saying he was fingered mistakenly and happened to fit the profile after cutting his hair shorter from an Afro in between the crime and his arrest. Nevertheless, he does acknowledge that he was engaged in other petty crime at the time.

Calvin served three and a half years in prison and six and a half on parole. He started to turn his life around while incarcerated, getting his GED, taking college classes and getting married. He saved a guard's life whose patrol vehicle turned over.

"After getting out of prison I went to work for an insurance company, but I didn't complete the training because the bills were catching up. I went to waterproofing and then job after job after job. I built experience to put myself in a position where I was more versatile and more marketable."

The 1980s ended up being a tough time for Calvin. "I started self-medicating when things weren't going so well. I did petty theft stuff and was working intermittently at the time."

Calvin has long since put those days behind him. He established himself as a law-abiding citizen and has been so for the past twenty years or more. "I did a lot of legwork that rebuts the arrests, but not the armed robbery conviction. It's the worst thing on my record. I did ten years that I can't get back."

Yet finding jobs has always been tough due to his past. "I've been paid eight dollars and hour, ten dollars an hour at companies well below my worth." He was denied a hazmat CDL because of his record. His current prolonged unemployment has been the worst.

"I was written off before I got a chance to put my foot in the door. I wouldn't hire me based on my record. The employer is responsible for a safe workplace. But companies dig deep into criminal history and don't think that people change. I am serving a life sentence."

Calvin's only current income comes from unemployment and SSDI. "There's no meeting basic needs on that. The budget needs to be well-planned. You can't go outside the box. You need a cushion for things like car and transportation problems and medications. I did receive food stamps, but I can't get SSDI and food stamps at the same time. I found out how important receiving food stamps really is. I've had to move in with my niece and together we take care of what we can."

Things are starting to look up for Calvin. He's become a WAGE (Workers Advocating for Greater Equality) advocate at the DC Employment Justice Center, and recently testified about his struggles before the U.S. House Judiciary Committee. The purpose of WAGE is to educate workers about employment law matters, provide advocacy and media skills, and help them identify and get involved in broad-based campaigns. He's going to vocational rehab now through Catholic Charities to become a certified addiction counselor and has some new prospects for employment.

"I want to help people avoid taking the route in life that I have. It's been a hell of a life."

Cross-posted from Defeat Poverty DC.

Education


Defeat poverty by investing early in our children

The surest way to break the cycle of poverty in D.C. is to start where it begins for so many in our city, at birth. We need to give our youngest and most vulnerable children the support and resources they need to thrive and have a bright future.


Photo by bixentro on Flickr.

As the mother of two young children, I can expound endlessly on why it is the morally right thing to do. But in this difficult economy, it also just makes practical and economic sense.

More than a quarter of children in the District live in families struggling in poverty, according to the latest Kids Count data reported by the Annie E. Casey Foundation. By providing low-income children with access to quality, comprehensive early care and early educationchild care and early learning programs that meet critical health, developmental and socio-emotional needswe can greatly increase their odds of success in school and over their lifetimes.

Research over the past two decades clearly shows that children's brains grow most rapidly between the ages of 0 and 3. In these earliest years, they form the vital brain connections that make later learning and development possible. In fact, if we miss this window to properly "wire the brain," no amount of remediation may make up the difference. (Click here to see an interactive brain map.)

It is devastating to think that if we don't reach children in time, they may be permanently impairedthrough no fault of their own.

It's not just the child who pays the price.

Study after study proves that when children from low-income backgrounds have the benefit of high-quality early care and early education, they are much more likely to become productive members of society and less likely to become dependent on government assistance as adults. Investing early helps prevent a host of social troubles, from truancy to teenage pregnancy, high school dropouts to violent crime and everything in between.

In classic economic terms, there is also a multiplier effect that springs from the productive intervention in the development of our youngest citizens. Parents who are assured that their children are being well cared for are more productive at work and are less likely to call in sick. Early care and early education is also a source of good jobs with health benefits to thousands in our city, who in turn make it possible for parents to work or go back to school to find better jobs.

In fact, economists have found that investments in quality early care and early education promise a much greater return than other social programs. And just as the health care industry is turning toward more preventative measures to save costs in the long run, it makes sense that those invested in education reform should do the same by prioritizing early childhood development.

It's particularly heartbreaking to think that some children in our city are barely given a fighting chance to thrive. The Kids Count data also reveal that infant mortality is actually rising in the District. At 13.1 infant deaths per 1,000 live births, it's nearly double the rate nationallyright here in the nation's capital.

If that isn't a wakeup call, I don't know what is. We need to speak up and act now for our youngest citizens. The future of our city depends on it.

HyeSook Chung is Executive Director of DC Action for Children. Cross-posted from Defeat Poverty DC.

Government


We saved transit, but everything isn't peachy for everyone

This week was a very exciting one for transit supporters. Not only did we reverse the DC Council's sudden cut to streetcars, but what started out as a massive set of service cuts were whittled down to none, at least in DC and Virginia.


Bread for the City provides holiday meals.

Yes, we have shown that transit matters to the residents of the region, and politicians should cut it at their peril. Transit service is very important to the less fortunate residents of our region as well, but it's not all that matters.

Metro fares are going up substantially. It's a better outcome than cutting service, and fares will go up more at rush hours which serve people who have jobs, but most of us probably make more money than the average worker. Most of us have jobs, but many people don't.

And in Prince George's County, the region's poorest, bus service is still getting cut.

The cost of health care for an elderly parent or sick child can drive families to and beyond the brink of bankruptcy. Many people who didn't grow up in families that had computers, read to their children on a regular basis, and sent their children to top schools need training to compete for today's knowledge economy jobs. Single parents find it difficult to afford decent housing. Homeless people often suffer from mental illnesses and cost a city more in police resources than it would take to treat.

As our political voice gets louder and elected officials start to listen more closely, let's be careful not just to advocate for the needs of the most fortunate residents of the region. With transit and development, they often go hand in hand, which is one reason I enjoy advocating for these so much. But we must still be mindful of the impact of changes we champion. More condos are great, but some must remain affordable for people at all ranges of the income spectrum. Transit is terrific, but it must serve all communities and at a reasonable price.

Save our Safety Net was pushing for new tax brackets for people making over $200,000 and then $1 million per year. As a resident who might well be in one of those tax brackets depending on the stock market, I can say for sure that I would not have been packing up to leave DC if the Council had enacted such a plan.

I didn't write much about the ongoing campaign because, frankly, I didn't have time to wrap my head around all the issues. For next year, we should do better.

But covering the needs of lower-income people and communities shouldn't wait until budget time. When we have debates about things like nutrition, some comments reveal that many people are misinformed about some of these issues. (For example, obesity in poor areas has a lot to do with federal subsidies for corn and high-fructose corn syrup.) We need to be taking the time to understand what life is like for folks who don't live in the nicest DC neighborhoods and richest suburbs.

The outpouring of energy for streetcars didn't just happen because we suddenly posted about streetcars when they were about to be cut. It happened because supporters, like Sierra Club, the Downtown BID, and DDOT had been building support for months. It happened because we had been talking about streetcars for months, and debating them, so that people could make up their minds.

To make a political issue successful, it isn't enough to talk about it when the time for action has come. It's important to talk about it beforehand and educate people who are sympathetic but haven't really thought about the issue thoroughly.

While I am not an expert on poverty, I would love for some folks who are to come start a conversation on a regular basis about how we can make Greater Washington greater for its neediest residents. If that's you, let us know at info@ggwash.org.

Demographics


Food desert or mirage?

Food security is an extremely important issue for the livability of cities. To educate citizens about it, accuracy in mapping is vital as well.

Upon first glance two weeks ago, I and a number of like-minded folks in the region sent along links and tweets to our contacts about "When Healthy Food is Out of Reach," a joint report from D.C. Hunger Solutions and Social Compact.

Sadly, it comes as no surprise that food deserts or or "grocery gaps," defined as an "area in the United States with limited access to affordable and nutritious food, particularly such an area composed of predominantly lower income neighborhoods and communities," exist in DC. Similarly, it comes as no surprise that, based on that definition, Wards 5, 6, 7, and 8 are the hardest hit.

However the maps used to convey the District's food deserts are misleading, particularly Maps 3 and 4 on pages 15 and 18 of the report. Below is an annotated version of Map 4, "Food Deserts in the District of Columbia."


Click to enlarge.

This illustrates what Mark Monmonier calls a "Blunder that Misleads" in his book How to Lie With Maps. According to the report, map 4 combines "census tracts where 51 percent or more of the population lives at incomes below 200 percent of the federal poverty level" and census tracts with "below-average access to full-service grocery stores."

The blundernot a lie but rather a "cartographic fallibility"comes from using census block group data. Entire block groups get designated as food deserts that either have no living residents (such as cemeteries and parks) and so do not have much income and require no access to food, or house institutions (like hospitals) and so do not have much income but likely provide food on site. Nearly 1/4 of the areas designated as food deserts may technically, but not realistically, fit the working definition.

Particularly during this time of increasing unemployment, homelessness, and hunger, advocacy groups across the District and the country are working overtime. Like many others, I want to help in the fight for social justice, but we need to be sure our data are airtight in order to effectively convey our messages.

Cross-posted at The District Curmudgeon.

Retail


"Bank deserts" harm underserved communities

The term "food desert," a neighborhood without sufficient access to healthy foods, has quickly become an accepted phrase for anyone thinking about cities. Now the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. has released data suggesting that the same phenomenon has been occurring with newly opened bank branches. They've been able to identity a pretty strong positive correlation between the siting of new banks and the median income of an area. Out of more than 10,000 branches opened in the last five years, only 1 out of 10 were placed in an urban location with high minority populations.


Photo by Thomas Hawk.

So what? Given all of the toxic asset and bank failure mayhem being announced everyday, it may seem that folks are better off if Citigroup doesn't want to set up shop on their block. However, without a physical bank within easy reach, many low-income residents have had no choice but to pay higher fees for check-cashing services, often businesses that also wave fast money in their face with unreasonable interest rates attached. The same demographic that may be more likely to receive a physical paycheck and less likely to have access to internet banking happen to be the ones who are being underserved.

I see this every day. There's a "payday loan" operation and two "Quik Mart"-type convenience stores right across the street from me. Why is it that expensive low-quality food and expensive low-quality financial services cluster together? It's probably because of a lack of market options due to spatial barriers and transportation infrastructure deficiencies. We can have a conversation about personal responsibility to eat well and make sound financial decisions, but as this data and my own experiences indicate, these decisions too often run into the simple barriers of geography.

page/2
DC Maryland Virginia Arlington Alexandria Montgomery Prince George's Fairfax Charles Prince William Loudoun Howard Anne Arundel Frederick Tysons Corner Baltimore Falls Church Fairfax City
CC BY-NC