Posts about Shoveling
Public Spaces
Suggested fixes to Prince George's snow removal policies
The Prince George's County Council will soon convene a public meeting with officials from the Department of Public Works & Transportation (DPW&T) to discuss the county's response to and management of the recent back-to-back snowstorms in February 2010.
The goal of this event, according to council chairman Thomas E. Dernoga (D-Dist. 1) and council member Samuel H. Dean (D-Dist. 6), is to review what happened and to determine what improvements are necessary to better handle future snow events.
On numerous occasions, I have personally experienced the negative ramifications of the county's currently inadequate and inefficient snow removal process, both as a pedestrian and a driver. Here are some suggestions for county officials to improve the snow removal process, particularly pedestrian and transit rider safety:
12 hours in denser areas: The County should immediately amend its sidewalk ordinance to state that all property owners and lawful occupants of vacant or improved lots in the Developed Tier and in Centers and Corridors are responsible for removing ice and snow from abutting sidewalks and away from abutting fire hydrants and drains within 12 hours after the precipitation ends (or by the immediately following noon, if the 12-hour period expires between 5:00 pm and 5:00 am).
- Sidewalks should be cleared to a minimum width of four feet and, if ice cannot be removed, the pathway should be treated with salt, sand, or other de-icing material.
- County inspectors (who could be specially trained, unpaid deputy volunteers, such as civic league members) should begin inspection/enforcement patrols no later than 18 hours after the precipitation ends.
- Properties in violation of the sidewalk ordinance should be photographed, cited, and fined (no warnings) and ordered to comply no later than 36 hours after precipitation ends.
- Properties not cleared by that point should be cleared by the county within 48-60 hours after precipitation, and the property should be assessed the costs of cleanup.
- Elderly and disabled property owners and occupants should be able to have snow removed at the county's expense or for a reduced fee. Absent or vacationing property owners should likewise be able to register with the county for a reasonable fee to have snow removed from their sidewalks.
- Street plowing in Centers and Corridors, and along commuter and school routes, should be done in a manner that will not obstruct sidewalks, bus stops, etc., even if that means that not all roadway lanes will be available. For example, a 2-lane road should be reduced to 1.5 lanes if plowing the full 2 lanes would block an adjoining sidewalk.
36 hours in other areas: All other county property owners (in the Rural and Developing tiers and outside of Centers and Corridors) should be required have snow and ice removed from sidewalks, fire hydrants, and drains within 36 hours after the snowfall.
- Systematic enforcement by the county of the snow ordinance in these areas would be optional, but inspectors would follow up on reports/complaints from neighbors and cite property owners appropriately.
- Properties found to be in violation should be ordered to comply within 18 hours following citation, and county cleanup would be provided within 36 hours following citation.
General policies:
- The County should be fully prepared at all times to handle snowfalls with accumulations of up to 12 inches. If greater accumulation is anticipated, the county's contingency plans should be designed to marshal the necessary outside resources and private contractors so that its regular snow removal time frames are not extended by more than 24-36 hours.
- All residential roadways in Centers and Corridors and in the Developed Tier should be made truly "passable" (i.e., no more than 3 inches of packed snow and properly salted/sanded) within 24-36 hours after a normal snowfall and should be plowed to bare pavement within 72 hours.
- The county should implement snowplow-tracking technology, such as that used in Howard County, so that DPW&T and the residents have up-to-date, real-time information on snow removal progress.
- County officials should post written updates on snow removal progress no fewer than once every eight hours for the duration of a snow emergency. It is inexcusable that even though the snow emergency that was declared on February 5 had still not been lifted as of February 18, the last official snow removal update we received from county officials was at 11:00 a.m. on February 10, in the midst of the second round of the blizzard.
- Within 6 hours after a declaration of a snow emergency, and before the snow starts to cripple the community, cars parked on snow emergency routes and on the odd-numbered side of non-snow emergency routes should be ticketed and, if they would interfere with snow removal efforts, they should be towed.
Do you have additional or different suggestions?
Pedestrians
Prince George's must ensure pedestrian and rider safety
We now know the ultimate price of Prince George's County's abysmal failure to clear the County's pedestrian pathways in a timely manner after the record-setting snowstorms earlier this month: People get killed.
On the morning of Thursday, February 18, 2010, 32-year-old Asa Fukuhara, a promising electrical engineer who worked for the U.S. Department of Agriculture and resided in Temple Hills, was struck from behind and killed by a hit-and-run driver as he walked the short 0.4 mile distance from his apartment complex to the Naylor Road Metro station.
How did this tragic accident happen? According to the Washington Post, "Police say they think Fukuhara was walking in the road to avoid snow-covered sidewalks."
These snow-covered sidewalks are within walking distance of a major public transit facility, and more than eight days after the last major snowfall of the recent blizzard. How can this be?
To be sure, the "Snowpocalypse" of February 2010, with its combined back-to-back snowfall accumulations of more than 30 inches over six days, shattered all previous records and was wholly atypical for the mid-Atlantic region. It wouldn't have made financial or practical sense for any local government in this region to be prepared to recover instantaneously from such an anomaly.
But Mr. Fukuhara didn't die in the immediate aftermath of the storm. This happened eight days later. The federal government had reopened six days earlier on Friday, February 12, and Metro had resumed normal operations at all stations and on all bus routes that same day.
Even the Prince George's County Public Schools had reopened the day before Mr. Fukuhara's accident, on February 17, albeit with some trepidation, "due to the severe snow and ice conditions of sidewalks and bus stops in the surrounding neighborhoods of schools."
The county's failure to ensure that sidewalks and other pedestrian and bicycle paths are promptly cleared of snow and ice It is the same twisted logic and sentiment that causes the county to build bigger and wider roads without adequate sidewalks and bike paths, and approve massive suburban sprawl developments rather than focusing on providing high quality transit- and pedestrian-oriented development in its already-urbanized transit-rich inner-beltway core. With those kinds of misplaced priorities, it is small wonder that the county now finds itself with more than 1,800 miles (and 5,000 lane miles) of roads to maintain.
After being deluged with citizen complaints, the County Council requested a briefing from the Department of Public Works & Transportation concerning its response to and management of the recent snowstorms. In his public statement requesting the briefing on February 16, council member Samuel H. Dean (D–Dist. 6), a current candidate for county executive in 2010, first expressed his thanks "that no great personal loss or misfortune occurred" as a result of the County's handling of the snow removal effort.
Sadly, two days later, Mr. Dean's declaration proved to be woefully premature, as Asa Fukuhara's unnecessary death bore witness to the tragic consequences of county's inadequate snow removal and pedestrian safety plans. Dean also wanted DPW&T to address particular "[c]oncerns around questions like what is meant by 'passable roads,' and why cul-de-sacs are prioritized differently from other streets." What was missing from the council member's statement was a request that DPW&T and/or the county's Police Department explain why, eight days after the conclusion of a snowfall—even a record snowfall—the county's pedestrian paths could not be made "passable" under any commonsense notion of that word for schoolchildren, transit riders, and others who depend on them.
But for the grace of God, I could have been Asa Fukuhara. Like him, I reside less than a half-mile from a Metro station (in my case, the Addison Road–Seat Pleasant station). On the same morning that Mr. Fukuhara set out walking to work, I, too, left my house on foot and headed to the Metro.
My neighborhood street, though "passable" for automobiles, contains no sidewalks, even though the county's plans have consistently called for all roads within the vicinity of the Metro station area to have sidewalks on both sides of the street. That forced me to march up the middle of the street—dodging cars as necessary.
Once I got to Central Avenue (MD-214), I faced the same situation as Mr. Fukuhara: the poorly-designed-but-nevertheless-existing sidewalks on this six-lane major arterial road were blocked by mounds of snow and ice, leaving me with no choice but to walk in the vehicle lanes on Central Avenue. I hoped and prayed, with each step, that some crazy, inattentive or inexperienced driver did not accidentally careen into me.
Fortunately, unlike Mr. Fukuhara, I made it to the Metro. And when I returned to the Metro station later that night, I had to repeat the same harrowing experience as I had earlier in the morning. Only this time, it was dark, and I'd already read the sad news about Mr. Fukuhara.
All of Prince George's County's citizens, including pedestrians and transit riders, should be afforded the ability and opportunity to travel safely throughout the county. County officials should make that happen, and we should hold them accountable for doing so.
Public Spaces
Shovel brigades clear out sidewalks and bus stops
While some people look forward to getting their street plowed after weeks of heavy snowfall, those who walk or use public transit to get around have a whole new problem: snowplows often push the snow into the sidewalk, leaving piles of hardened, icy snow several feet high.
No doubt you've seen people walking along the sides of major local roads, like Randolph Road in Montgomery County, Massachusetts Avenue in DC, and Columbia Pike in Arlington, as speeding cars swerve around them.
That's why we called for volunteers to shovel out sidewalks and bus stops across the region yesterday. The idea expanded upon the group in Tenleytown that Neil Flanagan and ANC 3E Chairman Jon Bender organized last Thursday.
Readers Marc, Paul, and Eric joined Dennis Jaffe and Stephen Miller to work along 16th Street in Columbia Heights. Hans Riemer, Kathy Jentz and Tina Slater attacked bus stops in downtown Silver Spring.
Others picked icy but high-traffic patches of sidewalk, like commenters mogwit and rallycap, who tackled the M Street bridge between Foggy Bottom and Georgetown, and David Alpert and reader Rob along Q Street across the Connecticut Avenue underpass.
The call inspired many to shovel out individual bus stops near their homes. Lance Brown worked on his stop at Benning Road and 16th Street NE, and RAC member Penny Everline and her husband shoveled in Clarendon. Even Washington Post technology columnist Rob Pegoraro wrote that he shoveled out his local stop.
Over a dozen neighbors from all over Tenleytown worked together to open up paths and make walking safe and easy again, including Ben Nieva, Mike Sires, Steve Kelley, Athan Manuel, Angie Das, Hedda Garland, Felix Garland, Jenny McCarthy and Chris Frantz, as well as some whose names Neil might not have recorded.
That group focused on the street corners, which had become less passable with every visit by the plows. The delay of one day had allowed most owners and businesses to clear their sidewalks, but the hardening slush in the streets was still tripping people up. They even put down some salt and sand provided by the local Ace hardware store. The Current sent out a reporter, who also recorded an audio segment for WAMU.
Unfortunately, snow on many busy sidewalks had already condensed into packs of ice, preventing the group from clearing more. David and Rob were only able to clear about 60% of the sidewalk across Connecticut Avenue after two hours.
Many businesses and organizations also deserve attention for their lack of effort. In Tenleytown, Neisha Thai and several other establishments south of the Metro stood out. Circle Management left their construction site next to the Metro uncleared, while they or their tenants fulfilled the responsibility on the rest of their properties.
The Georgetown Day School shoveled its 42nd Street Sidewalks well enough, but its long stretch of sidewalk on River Road was left completely untouched. Finally, the National Park Service proved the worst offender, shoveling none of their many properties around Tenleytown. There are similar stories in neighborhoods all around the region.
But while other people let down their neighbors, it was reassuring to see so many people out on a snow day, helping each other out. Everyone came away knowing the others a little better as well.
Public Spaces
Join the shovel teams at 3
We have three four locations set up so far for shoveling out bus stops this afternoon as Dennis suggested:
- Columbia Heights: West side Metro entrance (Dennis)
- Dupont Circle: North entrance at Q Street (David)
- H Street: 16th and H, NE on the north side to shovel out the X2 stop (Lance Brown)
- Georgetown: On the M street bridge from Foggy Bottom, to shovel the sidewalk (rallycap and mogwit)
Each will go from 3 pm to 4 pm. We'll shovel what we can in that hour.
There's also one tomorrow:
- New York Avenue: M Street entrance, Monday 10 am to 1 pm (Tony Goodman)
If you can join in any of these four outings (or organize another), please comment below to help us plan. There are plenty of bus stops and sidewalks that need shoveling, so if we have more people, we'll split into groups and tackle more areas.
For the Dupont one, I have an old garden shovel or two, which I will bring and any shovel-less participants can help break up ice. Based on that, we might try clearing the sidewalk where Q goes over Connecticut Avenue, which is very icy.
Dennis and I are going to buy a couple of extra shovels, assuming our local hardware stores have them have two extra shovels each. However, please bring one if you can. If you will show up but have no shovel, say so in the comments so we know how many to try to get; if you have extras you can bring, say that too.
Please continue spreading the word as well. Thanks to Prince of Petworth, Borderstan, and Richard Layman for posting about the effort.
Transit
Let's shovel bus stops Sunday
Give a hand. Save a hip. Bus stops all over the region are not safely accessible because of snow mountains, slush and ice. Taxpayer-funded Metro can't shovel out 12,000 bus stops. Let's make George Washington proud and go shovel.
On Wednesday, Neil's post recruited folks to shovel out inaccessible sidewalks in Tenleytown. Let's expand the program to other neighborhoods.
People are doing all sorts of ballerina and gymnastic moves while approaching buses. It's dangerous for them, and heck it slows down traffic, too.
We'll meet up tomorrow, outside Metrorail stations or at other set locations, at 3 pm sharp, armed with shovels. From there, we'll find bus stops in need and make them accessible.
Will you join in to melt our problems away?
If you're willing to commit to coming to a station, put the location in a comment. You can also pick another spot with high bus traffic that's not a Metrorail station. We'll send out a followup with the locations that got picked, to encourage more readers to join you.
After you pick a spot, send out an email to your neighborhood listserv to reach more of your neighbors.
I'm volunteering for Columbia Heights. I'll be at the entrance on the west side of 14th at 3. David will be at the Dupont Circle north entrance on Q Street. Who's in for those? And which locations will you organize?
Update: We have four locations so far. See the update post for details.
Public Spaces
Shoveling hall of shame: Dick Durbin and NPS
Dick Durbin has joined the ranks of Congressmen who pick on DC for its inability to instantly, magically melt several feet of snow that smashed the all-time record.
But Durbin might want to look a little closer to home for the source of some problems.
Along Pennsylvania Avenue, for example, the worst job clearing snow came from the National Park Service, part of the federal government in which Durbin is so influential. Commenter Kelly writes:
I walked in [Friday] morning ...along my usual route down Pennsylvania Ave SE and Independence Ave SE/SW.To be precise, while Seward Square (4th-6th Streets SE) is indeed an NPS property, the Eastern Market Metro plaza (7th-9th) was transferred to DC in 2006, and the District hasn't shoveled most of its parks either. Still, NPS has plenty of unshoveled spots all over the region. James, who lives off Georgia Avenue, writes,Residential and business sidewalks were well-cleared except for the blocks along Pennsylvania Ave SE maintained by the National Park Service (4th-6th / 7th-9th) which were completely unshoveled or plowed.
Although extremely frustrated about the lack of plowing on my side street, I've been understanding of the District's limited resources and limited plowing capabilities. What I don't understand, however, is how the National Park Service has neglected to shovel the long portion of sidewalk in front of Battlefield National Cemetery, located between the Takoma and Brightwood neighborhoods on Georgia Avenue.It's good that Durbin realizes that our snow response could be better. How about he talk to his friends on the National Parks subcommittee about holding a hearing into why the Park Service isn't doing its part?All the neighbors on the blocks around the cemetery, including a Safeway and a CVS have cleared their sidewalks after every snowfall. NPS has not. Seven days since the first flakes fell and not a single shovel has hit the cement. I've witnessed countless people make the decision to walk in the cleared, but dangerous, street rather than walk through the stretch of uncleared sidewalk. So, what's NPS's excuse?
In recent storms, they've plowed the freeway through Rock Creek while ignoring the walking and bicycling path. What was the agency's mission, again? But maybe that sits just fine with some of our Senators, who generally get chauffered by SUV from their homes to the parking lots at the Senate.
By the way, this is bizarre: the NPS directions page for Capitol Hill parks recommends taking the bus from Naylor Road on the Green Line to get to Seward Square, or a bus from Eastern Market and then walking three blocks when the park is just a single block's walk from the Metro. Marion Park (around 5th and South Carolina SE) suggests a bus from Anacostia with no mention at all of the one-block walk from Eastern Market.
Parking
Shoveling hall of shame: MarcParc
Reader Jeb sends along this particularly egregious example of failure to shovel. But in this case, they shoveled plenty, just not the sidewalks.
MarcParc is one of the large remaining surface parking lots in Mount Vernon Triangle. It occupies the entire block from 5th to 6th Streets NW between K and New York Avenues, adjacent to CityVista.
Jeb writes:
Immediately after the original storm this past weekend, MarcParc restored full parking availability on their lot but left every one of the surrounding sidewalks buried under feet of snow. Pedestrians have been forced to walk in the middle of dangerously busy avenues (K St, 6th, etc.) to get around the parking lot. In fact, it's not even clear how somebody who parked in their lot would safely get down to the nearest corner without dodging cars (and the huge spray of dirty meltwater they throw up as they pass).Jeb tried reporting the issue to 311 and DPW, as well as to MarcParc's central office, which hasn't returned his call. He says, "The man on duty at the booth acted unaware of the city's laws but said he would talk to his supervisor."
Pedestrians
Large buildings have no excuse for not shoveling
Property owners in DC, as in most other cities, are legally required to clear sidewalks adjacent to their property.
Most jurisdictions can't issue more than a small fine and rarely do, however, and legal liability is questionable. But icy sidewalks are a problem.
Greater Greater Wife, who as I've noted before is recovering from knee injuries, has lost much of her mobility because many sidewalks are too difficult to walk on. She's had to start taking taxis instead of the Metro.
Some homeowners are out of town and some can't shovel because of age or disability, but at the very least, the larger apartment buildings have no excuse. Most did a great job; some of the clearest sidewalks were outside big buildings, like the Cairo. But just to its east, the building at the northwest corner of 16th and Q hadn't shoveled. They have a very long façade on Q Street, leaving a huge expanse of sidewalk unshoveled. That made reaching the gym at the JCC very tricky for her.


They did seem to have the energy to clear their circular driveway nicely, however. Reg Bazile shared a picture of Paul's Liquor Store on Wisconsin Avenue in Friendship Heights, which also managed to clear their driveway but not their sidewalk.
For an individual house, there's a clear onus on the homeowner to shovel; I couldn't hope someone else was going to do our sidewalk. But for big buildings, especially rental buildings, the management company might not be interested in spending money to clear sidewalks and benefit from a little nudge.
Reader JohnMatthew had a similar problem. Yesterday, his 80 bus to the Kennedy Center stopped at 20th and Virginia. But he and some less mobile riders couldn't get there. He wrote, "There wasn't a plowed sidewalk within one block, so I, and two others with walkers, walked on a narrow (halfway plowed) street to the sidewalk. Ultimately, I couldn't get to work, because not enough sidewalks were plowed."
What do you think we should do? Should jurisdictions get more active about fining property owners, starting with the bigger buildings and businesses? Commenters debated throughout the day on yesterday's Breakfast Links about whether cities should require residents to clear sidewalks, or should tax people and handle it as a municipal service, like road plowing.
- Successful speed cameras require fair speed limits
- Amid scandal, don't lose sight of Gray's policy achievements
- Bethesda gets new but terrible bike racks
- Montgomery plans 160-mile, "gold standard" BRT system
- DC's parks are 5th best in the nation, says "Park Score"
- Live chat with Matt Yglesias
- DC's divide need not be black and white
Greater Washington
District of Columbia


















